Tonight on CBS 58 News at 10 - Online...

Tonight on CBS 58 News at 10 - Online penny auctions. Bargain or Ripoff?

There are 2 comments on the WDJT story from May 2, 2013, titled Tonight on CBS 58 News at 10 - Online penny auctions. Bargain or Ripoff?. In it, WDJT reports that:

Penny auction websites advertise great deals, up to 97-percent off of retail. We wondered if they are real or a scam, it turns out that it could be a little of both.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at WDJT.

“Authentic Social Bidding”

Since: Sep 12

Location hidden

#1 May 5, 2013
The penny auction model is fundamentally a fraud because of two issues, "chat mafia" Vs. "Bots".

1. The penny auction model is not compatible with "social features" like chat. When chat is added to penny auctions, bidders start making bidding arrangements:(Ginny don't bid on iMac and I won´t outbid you on the iPhone) which would make the house lose money. This is generally known in the industry as the "chat mafia".

2. The only way for the auction house to compete with "chat mafia" is by adding hidden bots.(bots=scam)

The only way to eliminate both of the evils and to add social feature support is by adding a funding phase.

So that each item goes through 2 phases:(see attached screenshot)

1. Funding Phase
2. Bidding Phase

Once an item is 100% funded it is opened for bidding.

The only way to get bids is by funding items:
$10 Get 10bids No Bonus
$20 Get 21bids 5% Bonus
$50 Get 55bids 10% Bonus
$100 Get 115bids 15% Bonus

Bids can be used on any item that is already opened for bidding. The last bidder can purchase the item at the final price.
phil

Saint Paul, MN

#2 May 7, 2013
socialshoppingnetwork wrote:
The penny auction model is fundamentally a fraud because of two issues, "chat mafia" Vs. "Bots".
1. The penny auction model is not compatible with "social features" like chat. When chat is added to penny auctions, bidders start making bidding arrangements:(Ginny don't bid on iMac and I won´t outbid you on the iPhone) which would make the house lose money. This is generally known in the industry as the "chat mafia".
2. The only way for the auction house to compete with "chat mafia" is by adding hidden bots.(bots=scam)
The only way to eliminate both of the evils and to add social feature support is by adding a funding phase.
So that each item goes through 2 phases:(see attached screenshot)
1. Funding Phase
2. Bidding Phase
Once an item is 100% funded it is opened for bidding.
The only way to get bids is by funding items:
$10 Get 10bids No Bonus
$20 Get 21bids 5% Bonus
$50 Get 55bids 10% Bonus
$100 Get 115bids 15% Bonus
Bids can be used on any item that is already opened for bidding. The last bidder can purchase the item at the final price.
That's a popular misconception, I wouldn't say it's a fraud. Saying that is like saying poker is a fraud. You may not win every hand, but it doesn't mean the hands you lost were a fraud because they cost you more than you got back. There are data services out there that provide assistance to penny auction players, like allpennyauctions.com , where you can see site reviews and decide for yourself if an auction is a fraud.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Fort Atkinson Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Donald E. Behling, 88, Fort Atkinson (Jan '16) Jan '16 kraig205 1
News Fort council advances community block grant (Feb '13) Feb '13 mary ann Steppke 1
News Activists see little-known UN plan Agenda 21 as... (Aug '12) Aug '12 american 1
News Fort group filmed for TV's 'My Ghost Story' (Jul '12) Jul '12 meme 1
News Governor Walker hits the campaign trail; Democr... (Apr '12) Apr '12 American Blueblood 7
News Public record for May 19, 2009 (Jun '09) Feb '12 OxyExpress 22
Debate: Gay Marriage - Fort Atkinson, WI (Jan '12) Jan '12 Melanie 1

Fort Atkinson Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Fort Atkinson Mortgages