Homeowner living in 2 towns wants twi...

Homeowner living in 2 towns wants twice the vote -

There are 61 comments on the Newsday story from Nov 6, 2007, titled Homeowner living in 2 towns wants twice the vote -. In it, Newsday reports that:

More than 240 years after American colonists employed the slogan, a Lake Grove man has resurrected the famous rallying cry: Taxation without representation is just plain wrong.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Newsday.

First Prev
of 4
Next Last
thogy

Peekskill, NY

#1 Nov 6, 2007
The man has a point.
if he has to pay tax into two separate, but equal, govenment juridictions, he should be able to vote in both.
To blame the boundaries as hundreds of years old is typical beaucractic BS.

Change the boundaries, or change the tax base, or let the man vote in each jurisdiction.

It will never happen though, as town or county employees are only outpaced in their non-production by their federal counterparts.
thogy

Peekskill, NY

#2 Nov 6, 2007
by the way, Newsday blocked out with four astericks the letters B and S adjacent to each other, as somehow it qualifies as obscene.
poconoweeze

Sunbury, PA

#4 Nov 6, 2007
thogy wrote:
The man has a point.
if he has to pay tax into two separate, but equal, govenment juridictions, he should be able to vote in both.
To blame the boundaries as hundreds of years old is typical beaucractic BS.
Change the boundaries, or change the tax base, or let the man vote in each jurisdiction.
It will never happen though, as town or county employees are only outpaced in their non-production by their federal counterparts.
First of all you spelled juristictions wrong. Not sure I spelled it right either. But I bet he isn't paying twice the amount in dollars for taxes. The towns are probably splitting it.
Give me a break

New Hyde Park, NY

#5 Nov 6, 2007
Okay, you got your pic in Newsday...you want to vote twice? Because you feel like it? Ridiculous.
jurisdictions webster

Amityville, NY

#6 Nov 6, 2007
The point is, he's paying taxes to both towns.They seem to think that his primary residence is in both towns.
I see his point. He should be allowed to vote in both at the local level. The problem is that the voting booths are not set up for it. It would be a headache to design a way for him and people in the same position as him to vote just for the local candidates in more than one town without giving them the opportunity to vote twice for county/state/national poisitions and referendums.
It would be too much of an opening to voter fraud.
LIC

AOL

#7 Nov 7, 2007
HE SHOULD GET TO VOTE TWICE, HE PAYS TAXES IN BOTH SO WHY NOT GET TO VOTE ON BOTH
Abbey Rhodes

Medford, NY

#8 Nov 7, 2007
one person, one vote....yes,it's that simple.
Abbey

Medford, NY

#9 Nov 7, 2007
Let him vote in Brookhaven and his wife vote in Smithtown.
Merry Old England

United States

#10 Nov 7, 2007
The last thing we need is to bend this voting law for land owners. If the law is changed, then it will become a case of landowners against serfs. No thanks.
Pat

Ridge, NY

#11 Nov 7, 2007
Seems like a typical rabble rouser...while one viewpoint says he should be able to vote in both localities...he only pays partial taxes in both so would only deserve a partial(half) vote in each town-yea voting machines would really accept that. AS for redrawing town boundaries, I'm sure he would think he gets to choose which town he is in and would end up suing for HIS choice..at our expense...ridiculous
Rob

New York, NY

#13 Nov 7, 2007
Here's an idea, redo the election district lines. They do it nationally for the House of Reps every 10 years with the Census. Redraw the lines so they the lines are in streets. Nassau and Suffolk County have changed drastically in the past 100 years.
ddarker

Bronx, NY

#14 Nov 7, 2007
He should vote in every town he sends tax money to.
ddarker

Bronx, NY

#15 Nov 7, 2007
On Long Island, the over-taxed property owners ARE THE "SERFS". A big chunk of income goes to taxes.
Debbie

Patchogue, NY

#16 Nov 7, 2007
Could someone please translate this into Standard English, "The house is in Smithtown - except where the corner where Brookhaven touches it?"
not nuts

Freeport, NY

#17 Nov 7, 2007
hey pal, your right to vote is based on your legal residence, which you are allowed one. Paying taxes is not a requirement to being able to vote. But you know this already...

Since: Jun 07

Copiague, NY

#18 Nov 7, 2007
Allowing him and those like him to vote in both townships would make a mess out of County, State and National Elections as they would appear on both booths in both locations. How do you limit voting twice on these elections and propositions? That might be possible only under an electronic system.

Maybe his taxes should be based on "where his bed is"
Karl Karlson

Hollis, NY

#19 Nov 7, 2007
Fix the district lines. Beyond that, who cares???
What is that all about

North Brunswick, NJ

#20 Nov 7, 2007
How stupid can you get? Abrahams needs something more to do.
Bemused

Hicksville, NY

#21 Nov 7, 2007
I like the idea that they decide where you vote by where you have your bed. That proves that they prefer the public to be asleep when voting. lol
Bemused

Hicksville, NY

#22 Nov 7, 2007
jurisdictions webster wrote:
The point is, he's paying taxes to both towns.They seem to think that his primary residence is in both towns.
I see his point. He should be allowed to vote in both at the local level. The problem is that the voting booths are not set up for it. It would be a headache to design a way for him and people in the same position as him to vote just for the local candidates in more than one town without giving them the opportunity to vote twice for county/state/national poisitions and referendums.
It would be too much of an opening to voter fraud.
He pays a share of his taxes to each town not the full amount maybe he could vote partially in both elections. lol

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 4
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Fire Island Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News MTA: Woman punched at Central Islip station, fa... Thu Doug Gee 2
News Cuomo proposes sweeping $11.5M plan to steer LI... Jan 16 time to sell 2
i want the old brentwood back (Apr '07) Jan 14 Jewel_and_Kaymac k 1,520
News Storm wallops LI roads, causing spin outs and s... Jan 10 positronium 7
News Islip, not Suffolk County, to give new park ran... Jan 10 best of luck 14
News Naked Man Sues For Dog's Right To Cruise Fire I... (Jul '06) Jan 8 liza 2
News Bankruptcy fight for '60s pop star Jay Black (Apr '06) Dec 30 Not Kosher 830

Fire Island Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Fire Island Mortgages