"schizophrenic" Town Meeting Shuts T...

"schizophrenic" Town Meeting Shuts Turbines Off and On

Posted in the Falmouth Forum

Sally Reynolds

Mattapoisett, MA

#1 Apr 6, 2012

Falmouth turbine votes go both ways

var isoPubDate ='April 06, 2012'By Sean Teehan

[email protected]

April 06, 2012

FALMOUTH They voted to shut the turbines off, then less than an hour later, they voted to leave them on.

In the fourth and final night of town meeting, members voted in favor of Article 23, a nonbinding petitioner article to shut off the town's electricity-generating Wind 1 and Wind 2 turbines until November. About 45 minutes later, when Article 27 a nonbinding petitioner article in favor of supporting the board of selectmen's plan to mitigate abutter complaints about the turbines came to the floor, they voted in favor of it.

"I would like to be quite honest, for those of you who voted for the previous article on the turbine and voted for this article, I would be very interested (to hear your logic) after the meeting," said Town Moderator David Vieira after Article 27 passed.

Both articles are nonbinding which means that selectmen are not required to adhere by the decision so the contradictory articles are both valid, Vieira said.

When asked about his thoughts on Article 27's passing, Malcolm Donald, a wind-turbine opponent, threw up his hands.

"I'm at a loss," he said outside the Lawrence School Auditorium Thursday night.

The debate over Article 23, which began Wednesday night before town meeting was adjourned that night, lasted almost an hour-and-a-half, with supporters of the article decrying the harm that some abutters say the turbines cause, and opponents calling for more research into the matter.

When the Wind 1 turbine was operational, some abutters complained the 1.65-megawatt turbine, located at the town's wastewater treatment plant, caused health problems such as migraines and vertigo. Wind 2 is also at the wastewater treatment plant, but farther from Blacksmith Shop Road.

Town meeting member Linda Tobey said she was disheartened when she heard fellow member Katheryn Elder and others say on Wednesday that selectmen had refused to allow wind opponents to speak at some of the board's meetings since November.

"When I heard them get up last night and heard them say that they went to selectmen meetings and weren't allowed to speak, I was appalled," Tobey said Thursday night. "I have lost faith in our selectmen that they are actually going to do what they say, because they didn't the last time."

Advocates against the turbines struck a deal with selectmen in November, when the board agreed to shut down Wind 1 and temporarily operate Wind 2 during a testing phase.

Wind 2's operation, which started in February, set out to test the reported effects on abutters in a 60-day trial. In its first 30 days, the turbine was spun without any curtailment. In the second 30 days, it adhered to the same restrictions the selectmen put on Wind 1 in February 2011, which included shutting down the turbine when wind speeds reach 23 mph.

A statement of principles detailing mitigation plans that selectmen accepted on Monday said the board intends to address abutters' concerns with actions including operating Wind 1 at 10 meters per second from April 17 to May 15. From May 15 to June 15, they would shut off both turbines between 10 p.m. and 6 a.m.

The plan would be responsive to Falmouth's need to generate $624,000 in electricity necessary to cover operating costs in the next fiscal year, said Assistant Town Manager Heather Harper during a presentation to town meeting members.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Falmouth Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Rutland, MA, most registered sexual offenders p... Feb 28 Boston Globe 1
Pillars of Hercules (Jul '14) Jan '17 anonymous 34
Hidden Wind Turbine Documents Could Prove Costl... Nov '16 Bob DeLeo 1
The Little Crooked House (Apr '12) Sep '16 David Evans 6
News Clinton campaign halfway to $1 billion fundrais... (Aug '16) Aug '16 Stephany McDowell 1
Does anyone know what happen to River Colt. (Nov '11) Aug '16 David 10
Vote for Hillary (Aug '16) Aug '16 Terry 1

Falmouth Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Falmouth Mortgages