Ellenville a City or just get rid of it?

Ellenville a City or just get rid of it?

Posted in the Ellenville Forum


Hurleyville, NY

#1 Sep 16, 2010
tell me what you think?



“Just the FACTS!”

Since: Apr 10

Ellenville, NY

#2 Sep 16, 2010
Get rid of it? As in nuke it or bury it under lava? Get real!

Look, you can dissolve the village government, but ELLENVILLE, as a hamlet, would still remain! IT would still need water, sewage, lighting, street maintenance, leaf removal, police coverage, building code enforcement, etc., etc. THAT will either have be done by the TOWN government, or separate special districts, overlapping and creating MORE bureaucracies, and MORE cost, OR they would have to do without such desired services. THAT is what the Ellenville Government Study Committee determined when asked to look at dissolution, so that option is not going to help or save costs.

A city, which would take some work, COULD solve some, but not all, of our problems.

I wrote about this YEARS ago, in Wawarsing.Net , and in the Ellenville Journal.

To see what I said then, go to:


(read http://journal.kryolux.us/PublicDomain33.pdf and http://journal.kryolux.us/PublicDomain34.pdf to understand the concept of "The People" as it relates to establishing a polity appropriate to its needs)

Schenectady, NY

#3 Sep 16, 2010
Rman wrote:
tell me what you think?
nuke it

“Just the FACTS!”

Since: Apr 10

Ellenville, NY

#4 Sep 16, 2010
"With or without the inhabitants, General Zog?"

Let us know when you have something useful to contribute, pal.

United States

#5 Sep 17, 2010
Krulick do you think the town could handle it?

Do you think taxes would go up if it was a city?

“Just the FACTS!”

Since: Apr 10

Ellenville, NY

#6 Sep 17, 2010
Town handle what?

First, a city gets to keep its sales tax; right there is a tremendous opportunity to hold onto revenue currently siphoned out of the village, AND to offer LOWER prices than in the rest of Ulster or Orange or Sullivan, hence attracting MORE stores and business into the village, and more shopping.

Cities have various advantages when it comes to getting money from the state, and can replace property taxes with a more fair and easier to administer income tax system, as Yonkers does, and many municipalities in PA or Ohio. But most services cost what they cost, and the change wouldn't affect that much.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Ellenville Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Hasidic school opens quietly in Bloomingburg May 24 Merkan Man 2
Review: Troy Reid and The Do It yourself World... (May '16) May '17 DrBill 12
Walmart Napanoch NY May '17 dan 6
News James Burke paid for sex in Oak Beach during Gi... (Dec '16) May '17 Mall Cop 8
Landord moving in all the black's to our town!!! (Jul '13) May '17 Moses Kestenbaum ODA 4
Contractor- Aaron Smith Mar '17 concerned 1
News Fear of taxes, or of Hasidim? (Sep '13) Dec '16 Moses Kestenbaum ODA 42

Ellenville Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Ellenville Mortgages