Girl stabbed in Perth Amboy home; sister questioned

Full story: New Jersey News

PERTH AMBOY, N.J. - A 14-year-old city girl was in critical condition at a Newark hospital Monday night after her 16-year-old sister allegedly stabbed her eight times during an argument.
Comments
41 - 60 of 60 Comments Last updated Jun 19, 2013
First Prev
of 3
Next Last
leoneClubDotOrg

Boston, MA

#43 Jul 2, 2008
They meant to say "stabbed her 8 times during a fight" and not during an argument. You can stab and argue.
Subhuman

Williamstown, NJ

#44 Jul 10, 2008
Ahhh yes. Perth Amboy. One of the best parts of this town are the luxurious apartment complexes such as Dunlap Commons on Zambory Street. So clean and crime free. Oh- and don't forget Cancoun Bar and grill right across the street. Such a charming place full of great towns folk who are delighted to have new-comers into their establishment. Why, they welcome you as you walk in and clean off a seat for you and your party to relax and enjoy the soothing music. It was only yesterday that I was having tea and crumpets with some of the locals when a police officer walked in and offered each of us a ride home if we had too much cider. How delightful!
GOODPOINT

Clifton, NJ

#45 Jul 10, 2008
leoneClubDotOrg wrote:
They meant to say "stabbed her 8 times during a fight" and not during an argument. You can stab and argue.
You make an excellent point. I would go so far as to say that the appearance of the knife or possibly the first time attempt at stabbing or cutting would be the transformative moment in the argument after which it is no longer an argument. A fight, stabbing or attempted stabbing maybe. But you are correct, clearly no longer just an argument
Noway

Sicklerville, NJ

#46 Jul 13, 2008
SALZUN- FROM PERTH AMBOY wrote:
<quoted text> EXECUSE YOU THIS HAPPENED IN PERTH AMBOY NOT IN WOODBRIGDE AND HOW DO YOU DEPORT SOME ONE WHO IS NOT A IMMIGRANT NOT ALL HISPANICS ARE IMMIGRANTS YOU TART.
Did U ever think to get her some help instead of putting a lable on her. Maybe she flipped 4 some reason & nobody saw the signs of help needed ???!!!
Noway

Sicklerville, NJ

#47 Jul 13, 2008
I think that there could have been signs before this fight came to a head that she could have been crying out 4 help & nobody took notice of any of it......... You also have to take into mind
was there trouble before this happened ! Was there a problem that everyone thought was fixed??
Now she will need Exstream medical help to find out " Y " this happened ! I do hope that the girl pulls out of this .
One n Only

Jackson, NJ

#48 Jul 23, 2008
i live in amboy, lived here since i was 5, its not a bad town people but i suggest do not move here, people talk too much shyt and everyone is in your bizz and as the crime thing well its been a trend lately that people wanna stab people!! But i knew that girl who stabbed the sister i would never think of her capable of doing that but u never know people flip and do stupid things i don't take her side but only the sister knows the story!!
anyi

Somerset, NJ

#49 Feb 9, 2010
i want yu all to please stop tlkin bout somethin u quisz dnt noee .. i appreciate tht it wasnt cuz of s hirt nuthin!

yes it was me so stop
anyi

Somerset, NJ

#50 Feb 9, 2010
n who r u one n only tht noes us?
anyi

Somerset, NJ

#51 Feb 9, 2010
n who the fck r u bride to me wtf u tlkin shit piece of shit u didnt noe ma sis more than me sucia!.. who the fck r u tosay shit u dnt noee huh? y u dntput ur name in there
blinx

Media, PA

#52 Feb 10, 2010
like erthan else i see tasteless an classless ova a muthafuckin shirt cmon b fareal nine out of ten times these chicken heads r jumps an was fighit ova a dude that doesn't want neither of their stank dirty asses fareal ppl wake da ufck up an get yous shit together an i typed it like this just in case they run cross it kuz its the only way they prob kno how ta read (chickenhead phonics) lmmfao
anyi

Somerset, NJ

#53 Feb 10, 2010
blinx w.e ur name is.. let me tell u i was tht qirl tht was stabbd n it wasnt cuz quisz nor shirts i want to make this facts straiqght leave this topic alone if u dnt noee .. she has her problems jsz leave it dnt make opinions tht rnt tru if u qyus dnt noe
anyi

Somerset, NJ

#54 Feb 10, 2010
i found this web n broke ma heart to hear wa pplsz say bout it.. i noee i been stabbd by ma sis but shes ma sis n i love her no matter her problems. the bible even tlk about the 2 brothers tht killd the other. n he was forqiven. i forqave ma sis i love her n even tho its not the same nomore but im qlad tht after wa happen we still tlk n we shared the same hous til a point she needed to leave . i appreciate some of u quisz support n love . im ok. i thnk qod im jsz finee.. somme of yall seen me out in amboy i still leave here not the same house im on ma own i have a kid so ma life is jsz fine thnksz to ma lord.. qod is qood he saved me, qave me another chance in life to see ma son n to c tru love of sis n famsz n friendds. n trust me if u forqive qod will qive u the biqqest qift ever..
anyi

Somerset, NJ

#55 Feb 10, 2010
smm wrote:
you dont the girl who stab her sister,
she is not crazy, is bad that she stabbed her sister, but no one can judge her, only she knew why she did it,
she had more strongs reasons to do it, the siste who got stabbed was not a good sister, always getting her in trouble with her mom , only people who knew her knows the truth and no ne else
who u r to tlk like tht .. i now who u is .. u dnt noe the house problem wit her . dnt believe wa u cnt c.. if u qo to ur mom sayin tht ur siblinqs r doin somethin wronq u qo n tell ur mom too so stop tlkinq bout me sayin im bad this n tht if u didnt even noe me well .. i noe who u is.. n i love ma sis . but u dnt qo n stab someone bcuz u c somethin not right n tryna help . if u a bad influence thnk qod she no lonqer tlkin to some of yall . cuz some of yall put her thinqsz in her head tht wasnt tru .. if u dnt noee wa went around home wit the thinqsz she said dnt tlk.. n the thinqsz her "friends" told her .. she tld me so u n some of others were bad influence n im qlad she realized n if she hasnt she will cuz i noee qod hae mercy for her soul n b forqiven...
anyi

Somerset, NJ

#56 Feb 10, 2010
Noway wrote:
I think that there could have been signs before this fight came to a head that she could have been crying out 4 help & nobody took notice of any of it......... You also have to take into mind
was there trouble before this happened ! Was there a problem that everyone thought was fixed??
Now she will need Exstream medical help to find out " Y " this happened ! I do hope that the girl pulls out of this .
they were sinqs n we tried to help!. but she didnt listen cuz bad friends she used to hanq out wit!
anyi

Somerset, NJ

#57 Feb 10, 2010
Maricela wrote:
I WUOLD HAVE DONE THE SAME EXACT THING AND SO WOULD ALL OF YOU !!!!!*****
u wouldnt stab ur sis .. thts a sin , sis no sis . u dnt do tht

Since: Apr 08

Bronx, NY

#58 Apr 28, 2010
anyi wrote:
i found this web n broke ma heart to hear wa pplsz say bout it.. i noee i been stabbd by ma sis but shes ma sis n i love her no matter her problems. the bible even tlk about the 2 brothers tht killd the other. n he was forqiven. i forqave ma sis i love her n even tho its not the same nomore but im qlad tht after wa happen we still tlk n we shared the same hous til a point she needed to leave . i appreciate some of u quisz support n love . im ok. i thnk qod im jsz finee.. somme of yall seen me out in amboy i still leave here not the same house im on ma own i have a kid so ma life is jsz fine thnksz to ma lord.. qod is qood he saved me, qave me another chance in life to see ma son n to c tru love of sis n famsz n friendds. n trust me if u forqive qod will qive u the biqqest qift ever..

I'm glad u came fwd ma...sometimes ppl read the articles n dont really kno the situation behind it & begin to pass judgement on things they really dont kno about...ignore them & 4give them 4 they kno not what they do!! God bless u & ur sister & I pray that everything goes well between u & that u guys can get past this & heal...
Perth Amboy Observer

New York, NY

#59 Aug 11, 2010
Seriously people. It's really not that hard to

LEARN HOW TO SPELL AND WRITE CORRECTLY!!!!!!!!!!

YOU ARE MAKING YOURSELVES LOOK LIKE IDIOTS!!!!!!!
Troy

Atlanta, GA

#60 Aug 12, 2010
No shock,, Amboy is a dump and going down fast
ss midle joson

United States

#61 Feb 8, 2012
Perth Amboy Observer wrote:
Seriously people. It's really not that hard to
LEARN HOW TO SPELL AND WRITE CORRECTLY!!!!!!!!!!
YOU ARE MAKING YOURSELVES LOOK LIKE IDIOTS!!!!!!!
i agreed lol
Jissel

Iselin, NJ

#62 Jun 19, 2013
My best friend is sisters with both of them and she told me that they fought over a boyfriend. shes out of jail now , shes in New York but thank god the sister is fine and alive. i just wanna get out of Amboy

Tell me when this thread is updated: (Registration is not required)

Add to my Tracker Send me an email

First Prev
of 3
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Elizabeth Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
The 25 Most Dangerous Cities in the U.S. Are Mo... (Nov '10) 1 hr Truthforthought 18,871
Any Gays/Bi's Near Elizabeth Nj? (Feb '13) 1 hr Ssoares12 13
I'm looking for a boyfriend 1 hr Ssoares12 1
The worst thing about flying? These people 14 hr One Leads To Another 1
Review: Tiger Supplies Inc. (Jan '14) Thu DrakeSpec 7
Review: Mango (Oct '08) Aug 26 LAPI 14
Review: Rich's Plumbing - 24 hour emergency plu... (Sep '12) Aug 25 Eugene Dean 5
•••

Elizabeth News Video

•••
•••

Elizabeth Jobs

•••
Enter and win $5000
•••
•••

Elizabeth People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

•••

Elizabeth News, Events & Info

Click for news, events and info in Elizabeth
•••

Personal Finance

Mortgages [ See current mortgage rates ]
•••