W.Pa. man gets probation for killing,...

W.Pa. man gets probation for killing, eating cat

There are 8 comments on the York Dispatch story from Feb 28, 2009, titled W.Pa. man gets probation for killing, eating cat. In it, York Dispatch reports that:

A western Pennsylvania man who killed and ate a woman's cat has been sentenced to probation for 23 months.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at York Dispatch.

James Conlin

United States

#1 Mar 1, 2009
Probation?! Let's talk about the incompetent judge who handed this laughable sentence down. This judge should be disbarred as an embarrassment to the profession. As a former Washington Co. law practitioner, I have half a mind to smack this fool upside the skull for such an idiotic blunder as this. The psychotic individual guilty of the crime against this animal WILL commit murder again, and we'd all better hope that it's not our sons/daughters next time. This is textbook, people. Pay attention. Shame on the pathetic excuse for a human being that is the so-called "judge" in this case. Should be locked up alongside this dangerous perp, as the menaces to society that they are.

“Phenomenal woman.. That's me. ”

Since: Apr 08

Somewhere in this vast world

#2 Mar 2, 2009
It all starts with the abuse of an animal.
Interesting

Lancaster, PA

#3 Mar 2, 2009
How would anyone know he actually killed the cat and ate it unless he told someone or someone else was there with him? Did he offer to share some with the neighbor? Being from a place called 84 doesn't lend to big city crime. Perhaps he was hungry and it was the only food he could find. Maybe he was developmentally disabled? Not saying what he did was right, let's just get all the facts in first before we pass judgement.
jim

Washington, DC

#4 Mar 2, 2009
Interesting wrote:
How would anyone know he actually killed the cat and ate it unless he told someone or someone else was there with him? Did he offer to share some with the neighbor? Being from a place called 84 doesn't lend to big city crime. Perhaps he was hungry and it was the only food he could find. Maybe he was developmentally disabled? Not saying what he did was right, let's just get all the facts in first before we pass judgement.
YOUR A FOOL
maybe hitler was just misunderstood
people like you are whats wrong with society
how much do you have to hhear before your dum mind says it can make a decision.
im sure if he was starving to death they the media would have said something about that
ofcoarse i shouldnt judge you because i havent seen all of your mental records yet
i hope the next time something like this happens to you or your family so that you will finnaly understand
Interesting

Lancaster, PA

#5 Mar 2, 2009
jim wrote:
<quoted text>
YOUR A FOOL
maybe hitler was just misunderstood
people like you are whats wrong with society
how much do you have to hhear before your dum mind says it can make a decision.
im sure if he was starving to death they the media would have said something about that
ofcoarse i shouldnt judge you because i havent seen all of your mental records yet
i hope the next time something like this happens to you or your family so that you will finnaly understand
Such a small mind. I really do believe you need to attend ESL classes before attempting to write again. Do you believe everything you watch on TV?
Tater Tot

Chambersburg, PA

#6 Mar 2, 2009
Just what is wrong with eating cat??? Did any of you ever eat Chinese food? How do you possibly connect eating a cat with killing people???? Not So!! Next thing your going to do is make the same connection with Steers, Pig, and Deer, Lamb.... you name it.... If he likes eating Cat.... so what... Good for him. You bunch of Hippocrates! Cat and taters go good together....LOL

Since: Jan 09

Middletown, PA

#7 Mar 2, 2009
Tater Tot wrote:
Just what is wrong with eating cat??? Did any of you ever eat Chinese food? How do you possibly connect eating a cat with killing people???? Not So!! Next thing your going to do is make the same connection with Steers, Pig, and Deer, Lamb.... you name it.... If he likes eating Cat.... so what... Good for him. You bunch of Hippocrates! Cat and taters go good together....LOL
Sequeway to the Chinese Buffet that is serving Roach Rellenos and Cat Chow Mein!!!
Who Cares

Harrisburg, PA

#8 Mar 5, 2009
Bozo Girl wrote:
<quoted text>
Sequeway to the Chinese Buffet that is serving Roach Rellenos and Cat Chow Mein!!!
Here Here. We all know that this will now be another drain on our tax paying dollars.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Eighty Four Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Jay’s dispen-sary. A d d y s IRs n XR etc May 8 Jayson 1
News Notices Apr 24 Chestnut Ridge PA... 1
TOKAR surname (Nov '07) Apr '18 ChrisE 4
News Pennsylvania Election: Regional Race Could Offe... Mar '18 Cordwainer Trout 2
Getting annoyed at the aggregate making noise r... Jan '18 annoyed 1
Coyle trucking Dec '17 Smart 1
Dean Eble (May '07) Sep '17 Sad 13

Eighty Four Jobs

Personal Finance

Eighty Four Mortgages