murder suspect short of confession

The man accused of killing his former girlfriend is being held without bond in the Montgomery County jail. Full Story
First Prev
of 2
Next Last
dman

Mishawaka, IN

#23 Mar 13, 2009
Im still waiting to hear the rest of the storie. Could it have been a home invasion,burglary, rape kidnap. was this man defending his home and accidently shot the girl? Do we know the background of Mr.Lyman? Does he have a criminal history? these are all questions that need to be asked before judgement is passed.
Tina Crouch

Lombard, IL

#25 Mar 13, 2009
Hello, and yes I do I am a activist for the death penalty in United States , thank you for your well felt concern that I may be on welfare It is amazing how some people feel computers are not the wave of the future. Actually this is and will be a huge publicized case and will be one of the major criminal acts of the year and I will be there from day one. I have alerts set on several sites to this very story. I am sorry if you feel it is a bother and yes I do like to comment on forums when it comes to education and other topics that relate to the future of our country. This is who I am and I am very proud of myself in all aspects of my life,career and choices I make.I would prefer to keep this about the actual topic at hand though and that would be a loss of a life taken by another human being. I understand you are a angry for this is a friend of yours and believe me when I say I do understand your compassion to him, though I must say my compassion lye's in the victims family for they truly are more confused and hurt more than anyone of our words will ever explain. They are the victims and we as Americans must separate who the victim and the assailant are and expect swift justice for crimes in our country.I understand and respect you do not believe in the death penalty all I ask is you respect my opinion that we can not keep overloading our prisons to comfort someone who does not have the right to ever be released from our prison system, the financial responsibility to it seems frivolous and at least most states offer lethal injection to end a criminals life unlike the many different ways that the victims are killed everyday.
tina needs a life wrote:
Tina you have to much time get a real life. Must not have one you are always here do you even work?must be on welfare. Cause you are always here. You have comment on all these.
Tina Crouch

Lombard, IL

#26 Mar 13, 2009
Thank You for reminding me there are several bibles I do sometimes forget there is no wrong religion as long as it is a faith that allows us to realize good from evil.. I do read the from the Holy Bible and the verses I recognize and follow to 'a eye for eye' is from Matthew 5:48 you may follow up on it if you would like . I will say that you are correct on the turning the other cheek but for some this is not what they feel they can do so this is why we have court systems to deal with criminals in a appropriate way. I am sorry you are confused on the story you as a citizen are aloud to court documents and records of criminals in your community of where you live simply by requested them . Have a great afternoon.
dman wrote:
in response to tina. What bible do you read because mine says to forgive, and turn the other cheek. Not kill.
are you kidding

Indianapolis, IN

#27 Mar 13, 2009
He has no room to talk!
Danielle

Council Bluffs, IA

#28 Mar 14, 2009
Rest in peace Heather, I only got to meet you a few times and I loved your personality. Shopping with you on black friday last year was really fun and i still have the shoes you bought me, i will keep them forever. John as you know is my brother and you were his wife. you ment the world to him, i have never seen him cry the way he has for you. we all loved you and still do. Your children are in Gods hands hun no need to worry. God Bless you, Heathers family. RIP Heather Rush.--Danielle Coonce
Julie

Council Bluffs, IA

#29 Mar 14, 2009
I never met Heather, but have known her widowed husband for 18 years. He is hurting really bad right now and I hate to see him like that! I have heard a lot of great stories about her and how much she loved her kids! Noone ever deserves to die the way she did and her oldest kid definitely didnt deserve to watch her mother die in front of her. Heather, you will always be remembered! Rest in peace!
shut up

United States

#30 Mar 14, 2009
anonymous wrote:
Heather was a tr*mp. She was bisexual and sexually promiscuous. She was also a drug user and lair. I knew her well. She got what she deservered
A woman is dead and this is all you have to say?? No wonder our country is the way it is. Now we think it is okay for some people to be killed. I don't care what she did or who she offended. Killing someone is always wrong unless it is self-defense. Whoever, wrote this needs to get a clue. I hope the family of the woman who lost her life is doing as well as can be expected. May God give you grace during this difficult time.
the babysitter

Crawfordsville, IN

#32 Mar 17, 2009
i just want to say that i was at the showing for heather and honestly it doesn't matter what anyone says anymore he took her life end of story but honestly none of you would be saying the things that you are saying if you saw the was that sierra was hurt and crying you all need to think about that and not the things she did or didn't do
Lauren

Kouts, IN

#33 Mar 18, 2009
Wow, That's all I can say...I was close to Heather and have many memories with her..She was my brother-in-laws sister..How can you people be so F*cked up to judge, i got on here and was truly hurt and deeply saddened by what is being said..Yes she could have done bad things in her life..but she was a Great mother and friend! if you could only see Sierra,(and thats her oldest daughter)since many of you dont even know the family well enough to say good from bad..,She was deeply hurt! And for my sister and brother-in-law that have the two youngest children(SCOTTS) and have to hear them say mommy, it hurts them bad! and this stuff about Scott, You also need to realize his family his hurting now too! The only difference these families face is Scott is alive and can he talked to and seen, Heather is not! Although neither families will have anymore memories to come! Against all odds and a million different stories, nobody should have died as a result! JUST STOP JUDGING, and i will do my best to keep my brother-in-law and sister from logging into this site so they dont have to see more hurt! THANKS!!
Lauren

Kouts, IN

#34 Mar 18, 2009
anonymous wrote:
Heather was a tr*mp. She was bisexual and sexually promiscuous. She was also a drug user and lair. I knew her well. She got what she deservered
Thanks for being anonymous, because if you werent, you would get what you deserved, to GO TO H*LL!! but's okay God knows who wrote this!
the babysitter

Crawfordsville, IN

#35 Mar 18, 2009
anonymous wrote:
<quoted text>
She toyed with men and thier emotions. I was one of her victims. I was also involved in several 3somes with her. She was always cheating on men and emotionally abusing them. She also smoked pot and used crack. This is why one of her children had down syndrome...TOO MANY DRUGS.
in reference to this comment about the downs syndrome. you really need to take a look at a science book sometime children aren't born with downs due to the mothers use of drugs.it happens when the chromosomes are lining up during the early stages of birth and everybody carries the gene to pass it to the child and it is not proven which parent gives the child the gene but it is proven that it is a chromatic disorder and nothing to do with drugs. and you obliviously don't know much and are going off of assumptions. and how dare and honestly if that was the case then don't you think that more of here children would have it and not to mention that but a lady at my church has a daughter with downs and she doesn't do drugs at all so please everybody just leave this alone the family is hurting enough and this is not helping. talking bad about the children's mother gets you no where it may make you feel better at night when you sleep but it doesn't help the situation and what the family is going through so please just end it now
are you kidding

Indianapolis, IN

#37 Mar 19, 2009
double wide wrote:
It was ended last week - the commenting stopped. Now you've gone ahead and brought this topix back on the list. move on
Why? you do not live in this area, Penn is a little far for some one to tell some one what to do!
If you think you can stop it why don,t you come here instead of hiding behind the keyboard you CS, MTF,
Right here in Lafayette, Indiana. OTHER WISE MORE COMMENTS on there way!
TLH

Indianapolis, IN

#39 Mar 19, 2009
double wide wrote:
<quoted text>
Hey genius, its an ISP location, like yours in Indianapolis. I'm no where near Pennsylvania, and the location may change at any time. Comment all you want, I don't care either way, it can be comical. My keyboard is not large enough to hide behind, and why on Earth would I want to go to Lafayette?
Oh..what was your comment regarding this topix?
didn't have one? ok, I gotcha
I Live Lafayette You say enough on comment on this situation well I and others from this area won,t! If you want to sit your F A there and tell people what to do. Bring it! thats why I say bring it to Lafayette if thats all you can do is hide you CSA, until then I like others are going to comment on it and there isn,t a damn thing you can do about! except that! GOTCHA!
TLH

Indianapolis, IN

#40 Mar 19, 2009
Gothcha both!
TLH

Indianapolis, IN

#41 Mar 19, 2009
are you kidding wrote:
<quoted text>Why? you do not live in this area, Penn is a little far for some one to tell some one what to do!
If you think you can stop it why don,t you come here instead of hiding behind the keyboard you CS, MTF,
Right here in Lafayette, Indiana. OTHER WISE MORE COMMENTS on there way!
Get of the topix no one can understand a loser like you anyway
Tim

Indianapolis, IN

#44 Mar 19, 2009
I just pray that this all gets over soon. Come on everyone can,t we all just get along!
Concerned

Middleton, WI

#45 Mar 23, 2009
dman wrote:
Im still waiting to hear the rest of the storie. Could it have been a home invasion,burglary, rape kidnap. was this man defending his home and accidently shot the girl? Do we know the background of Mr.Lyman? Does he have a criminal history? these are all questions that need to be asked before judgement is passed.
I do know the character of Mr. Lyman. He is a coward who only fights with women. He was arrested 2 weeks before Heather's murder for residential entry and resisting law enforcement...guess where he tried to break in....Yes, Heathers house. She is the one who called the police on him. And by the way..if this has anything to do with character..mr lyman is over 25,000 dollars behind on child support of his 2 children. Sounds shady to me, why would he go to the bathroom while she was being tortured by scott?
TLH Hater

Rensselaer, IN

#46 Apr 20, 2010
TLH wrote:
<quoted text> I Live Lafayette You say enough on comment on this situation well I and others from this area won,t! If you want to sit your F A there and tell people what to do. Bring it! thats why I say bring it to Lafayette if thats all you can do is hide you CSA, until then I like others are going to comment on it and there isn,t a damn thing you can do about! except that! GOTCHA!
Wow, you are not only cruel you are stupid and make yourself look so on here. God knows you and all you have done and just remember
"karma is a bitch" Rot in hell.

Since: Aug 10

Indianapolis, IN

#47 Aug 2, 2010
Does anyone have any updates on this case?
omfg

United States

#48 Aug 8, 2010
To tina needs a life! Let me tell you something I am really sick of people posting about people on welfare! Maybe some people aren't as perfect as you act you are anf can't help it! So shut up about people on welfare!!

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 2
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Crawfordsville Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
rehab center Dec 14 NoWay 2
Wreck just west of Crawfordville on I-74 nov29th Dec 11 squeezers 4
Ladoga Acedemy is closing down. (Apr '09) Dec 11 Darrell 20
indiana childrens christian home (Aug '09) Nov 23 adam malone 14
Tired of BS? (Apr '14) Nov 23 squeezers 2
Fredrick R. "Fred" Hitch, New Palestine (Aug '11) Oct '14 Judith Hitch Boots 2
Ebola Land Oct '14 squeezers 1
Crawfordsville Dating
Find my Match
More from around the web

Crawfordsville People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

Crawfordsville News, Events & Info

Click for news, events and info in Crawfordsville

Personal Finance

Mortgages [ See current mortgage rates ]

NFL Latest News

Updated 11:39 am PST

Bleacher Report11:39AM
Complete Week 16 Preview for Indianapolis
NBC Sports12:33 PM
1 thing even Rahm can't fix: Da Bears - NBC Sports
NBC Sports 1:01 PM
Cowboys' Murray listed as questionable for Colts - NBC Sports
NBC Sports 8:26 AM
Report: Executives suggest Bears could have to attach a draft pick to move Cutler
Bleacher Report11:56 AM
Eagles vs. Redskins: Live Score and Analysis for Philadelphia