Who has the BEST pizza is Columbus?

Who has the BEST pizza is Columbus?

Created by ___Lorri___ on Jan 30, 2013

1,469 votes

Click on an option to vote

Mellow Mushroom



Johnny's NY Style




Little Caesars


Pizza Hut

Since: Oct 10

Pittsview, AL

#33 Mar 28, 2013
Sweet Kiki wrote:
I like Picasso and that whole area around is fabulous
I agree, ;)
How you been? PM me here or there.

Since: Feb 13

Columbus, GA

#34 Mar 28, 2013
Chef Boy Ar Dee wrote:
P I zz A
Funny Video
Food critic

Phenix City, AL

#35 Mar 29, 2013
Picasso's is hit or miss, when they are on, that got everyone beat.
Peluso's is thin crunchy crust heaven and the sauce is fantastic.
Marco's, hands down the best chain store pizza.
Mr Snyder

Columbus, GA

#36 Mar 29, 2013
David M

Columbus, GA

#37 Mar 30, 2013
I guess I like all pizza

Columbus, GA

#41 Mar 31, 2013
I used to like Pizza Inn buffet. I went to the new buffets at Stevie B's but the are ok but not as good.

“Shadowville All-Stars”

Since: Dec 08

Columbus, GA

#42 Apr 2, 2013
Columbus Pepper wrote:
All these top vote getters are fine places.
I remember the best pizza ever in Columbus was a place up on the corner of Manchester Expressway and Armour Road, I believe there is a car lot there now.
The place was called "Pizza Square" and sold square shaped pizza in a diner style facility.
The sauce was the best I ever had and the pizza was great.
I agree with the poll about Peluso's and Piccasso being about the best in town at this time.
I found a great old photo of Pizza Square, I'll try to post it here, soon.

That corner is also memorable as the location for Mark Levy aka The Wizard of Cars.

“I see you”

Since: Oct 10


#43 Apr 2, 2013
I am going to go with Mellow Mushroom, Columbus Topixers!

Columbus, GA

#45 Apr 2, 2013
These places must all e good cause if your pizza isn't good, you want be in business long. That is just how it is in the pizza business.
Harold Hardrada

Columbus, GA

#46 Apr 3, 2013
P N O wrote:
These places must all e good cause if your pizza isn't good, you want be in business long. That is just how it is in the pizza business.
Like Pizza Inn, Parnello's, Casa Italia. They were terrible and all now DEFUNCT!
Piccasso, Peluso's Cafe Amice, etc. Good food and have been around for a long time now.

Columbus, GA

#48 Apr 7, 2013
I love pizza. A few missing on the poll but hey, its not my poll.

Columbus, GA

#50 Apr 11, 2013
Little Ceasars 5 buck carry out

Columbus, GA

#51 Apr 13, 2013
I like Marco's alot. Good pizza for delivery
Dred Scott

Lawrenceville, GA

#52 Apr 14, 2013
Picasso reigns supreme

Columbus, GA

#53 Apr 18, 2013

Talladega, AL

#54 Apr 20, 2013
I like Piccassos when I'm in Columbus.

Columbus, GA

#55 Jun 6, 2013
Pizza the Hut

Columbus, GA

#56 Jun 7, 2013
Its not delivery

Since: Feb 13

Columbus, GA

#57 Sep 21, 2013
Peluso's is the clear winner on this one, some new places in town since this poll was created though.

San Antonio, TX

#58 Oct 1, 2013
Smith Station Panthers wrote:
I have to wonder why my previous post is being judged "Racy" "Touching" and even more crazy "Off Topic"
Crazy stuff going on on this board.
it's because of the twinkie flame/spam trolls haunting these boards.

even that guy riceboy won't return because of them.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Columbus Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
*keep a word- drop a word* Game (May '15) 1 hr GEORGIA 740
Word Association (May '15) 11 hr Yetti 391
News Donna D'Errico visits Columbus for showing of '... Mon Zack 2
Help me find family Apr 29 Nitetrain 1
Radio disc jockey in Columbus (Jan '15) Apr 28 Will Dockery 21
Obama's Dystopian Society Apr 18 David53 2
Looking to breed male toy poodle (May '12) Apr 13 Patty 32
More from around the web

Personal Finance

Columbus Mortgages