Guest

Lizella, GA

#21 Aug 7, 2010
Doesn't matter if he lives here or not. She can still sue the holy crap out of him here in TN where the crime took place. He will have to defend himself here. And when she wins, they can attach his wages, put a lean on his house and everything else he owns no matter where he lives. I hope his wife left him.
tom

Celina, TN

#22 Aug 7, 2010
Why was there no trial?Did this even go to grand jury?For this not to go to trial something had to be agreed upon.
Chellie

Baxter, TN

#24 Aug 7, 2010
The D. A. came to me and told me word for word. This man has no previous criminal history. He would qualify for the Diversion Program and that we could go through with a trial but the program he would be on would show nothing on his record after 1 year and also that at no point now or in the future regarding this case would he have to register as a sex offender. So in all our county officials say "come to our town rob us, rape our children and we won't do a thing to you.
tom

Celina, TN

#25 Aug 7, 2010
This should have went in front of the grand jury and then to criminal court and on to trial. The fact that it went in front of Judge White and stayed there should mean they agreed to let Judge White decide it or they settled on an outcome.
Chellie

Baxter, TN

#26 Aug 7, 2010
guest wrote:
Get the real facts. Last time I checked the man accused did not even live in the state of Tennessee, Mom does not work for Child Protective Services and obviously there was more to the case than what you are saying or the man would not have gotten off with simple assult. Anyone who knows these people know that they would not support anything close to this. People make sure your facts are true before you go judging and assuming things.
Now to respond directly to you. The facts are all of public record. I will be more then happy to post them on here as well as in the local news paper, and I might ad including but not limited to the Local News stations. Two things need to change in this situation. First and Formost our laws that are supposed to help protect our children. Second the Community has every right to be aware that a family whom seeks babysitters for their children are a threat, considering my daughter was raped in their home. And furthermore they stood by their Son who raped a 15 year old girl. Let me repeat this was a child, he was an adult 24 years old. Furthermore he provided her alcohol that came from Karens liquor cabinet. She paid for my daughter to be given alcohol.
Now to comment on the judgement. When I met Karen and Matt Butterworth I felt as if they were very outstanding people. People whom had very big hearts, who took children into their home that had been beatin and severly neglected. Matt comes off as a very stable but stern man. With good character I might ad. Karen came off as a very loving person, whom appeared to be honest. Whom had a bad or not so wonderful childhood and wanted to make a family what she thought family should be. She seamed strict but loving. For all that I could see the family was very well rounded. Karen knows that my daughter loved her and her family and in no way wanted this to be what it is. She hated having to tell me that Kevin did this because it would destroy Karens family. This child has been raised well and is very concerned for others. However in this process you cannot sit on the fence when you have taken an oath to protect the children of this world. She stood by Kevin and smiled knowing that he was only being convicted of simple assault. Which he plead to on his own free will. Innocent people don't consider plea agreements at all I might ad. She can say what she wants now but she told my husband and myself both that she wanted him charged and that she herself would kill him. But in that same note this ever so rounded family spends lots of time in the bars getting drunk. By the way this is a small town many people have seen her. This well rounded mother went to GT's with and left her kids in the car so she could go inside and buy sex toys. Which others have seen. Also she has been drinking and got behind the wheel with her children in the car too. Now granted no one is perfect but for a woman who makes decisions on the job that either a child is to stay with their foster parents or not wouldn't you think she should be holding herself to a higher standard. Lead by Example correct. So her examples are leave my kids in the car while I go in a bar, drive after I have been drinking with and without my kids, and ALLOW MY 24 YEAR OLD SON IN MY HOME ALONE WITH A 15 YEAR OLD BABYSITTER AND ALL THE ALCOHOL THEY WANT SO SHE CAN BE RAPED ON THE FUTON COUCH IN THE BASEMENT OF THEIR HOME. And she smiles in the end that he got off virtually scott free. But what she didn't know is the drinking game he played with my daughter he was also playing with her daughter he just didn't give her alcohol. He is priming her to be ready in the next couple of years! So you get your facts because there is 7 hours worth of taped investigation facts that I have. There are reports from day one of every single event and statement made by all parts since this started and more then just the media will have access to it!!
Concerned

Cookeville, TN

#27 Aug 7, 2010
15 IS a child people! Childlike or not, a fifteen year-old cannot legally give sexual consent!! Doesn't matter where the man lives anyway if it happened here. The parents are very good people and there must be much more to the story without blaming the teenager.
curious

Celina, TN

#28 Aug 7, 2010
How long after this incident did your daughter let you know what happened? Was there a rape kit or any physical evidence?
Hurt

Celina, TN

#29 Aug 7, 2010
Who was the District Attorney that negotiated this outrage? Was it Randy York or Assistant DA Gore from Livingston? Your daughter will be in my thoughts and prayers. Too many Attorneys are way too cozy with DA's and Judges. This is not even a grey area, this is black and white. Do not stop fighting! This will be no easy journey, the courts here perpetuate themselves from within their ranks. Few folks here have the financial means to seek Federal intervention when County and State Courts fail us. Last resort--60 minutes----20/20. So very sorry.
OMG

Celina, TN

#30 Aug 7, 2010
Well this is the biggest bunch of bologna i have ever heard. To set the record straight for some of you people. i am a very close friend of this family that you criticize on here. i have sit side by side with this family through this ordeal and have set in with the lawyers on the deal. This story that this family has made up is the biggest crock i have ever heard. there is no evidence in the matter no matter what the family says. even if there is 7 hours of investigatve tapes there is nothing where the defendent states where he ever done anything. its easy to make a 15 yo say things that you want them to say especially if you have ever met this 15 yo. and also to set the record straight he did not get off these charges because he has no criminal record he got off because there is no proof of the false and malicious accusations that he was charged with. and if your wandering why he plead to simple assault its because he has no money to pursue the matter further. and for the money he has invested it was a good deal. would you take a simple assault over prison or the sex offenders list? i believe so but i also no that this family followed the defendant after the court house and made several threatening remarks.even as far as killing the defendent. with my professional knowledge thats a threat and verbal assault in itself. what it all boils down to for you people who have never met this family that would charge an innocent person with such a crime is that this family is dishonest trailer trash and not to be trusted thierselves.they thought they could get some money out of the deal and prolly wished he would have settled for a price. if you want to know who not to trust its them. watch your back cause god knows what they will try and charge you with.
whatever

Baxter, TN

#31 Aug 7, 2010
Get a life people. These people are not like this at all. I know them personally. And since you posted names this is now a slander suit. Im sure u will be hearing from lawyers soon...funny thing is u post their name but not enough guts to post ur own. must be lies...total lies...
Chellie

Jamestown, TN

#32 Aug 7, 2010
My name is posted right here. I am not hiding at all who I am. Nor will I allow another to hide the sick person that they are. As far as a threat. I made no such threat at all. The facts are I MADE A PROMISE! As far as their money. Everyone here who knows me knows I have no need for their money I HAVE MY OWN. Personally I have never lived in a trailer and by all means I am not trash either. I am sure that many here in Celina will find it very interresting that you take a strong stance against people in trailers. And by all means my daughter did not make up any lies. Karen was even given an opportunity by me to interview her. Karen chose against it because she didn't want to hinder the investigation. If you walked the path with this family you would already have been aware of that. So who is lieing here. And as I said earlier the focus is that a 24 year old man had gave alcohol and raped my daughter, the community has every right to be aware that this is in their back yard and that they need to be aware.
STFU

Buffalo Valley, TN

#33 Aug 8, 2010
explain wrote:
this is celina.. ppl in celina embrace these type of ppl and take up for them. Trust me if you want something to happen push further. celina is full of fake ppl.
You are a jackass trol, and know nothing about real clay countians. Mnay mano of, not all, but many of the thousand or so who have settled here in the last few years have brought many vile elements to our county, but are nor representative of the real Clay County,
Jim

Buffalo Valley, TN

#34 Aug 8, 2010
Hurt wrote:
Who was the District Attorney that negotiated this outrage? Was it Randy York or Assistant DA Gore from Livingston? Your daughter will be in my thoughts and prayers. Too many Attorneys are way too cozy with DA's and Judges. This is not even a grey area, this is black and white. Do not stop fighting! This will be no easy journey, the courts here perpetuate themselves from within their ranks. Few folks here have the financial means to seek Federal intervention when County and State Courts fail us. Last resort--60 minutes----20/20. So very sorry.
I have known Randy York for the better of 40 years. He is honest and of high integrity. He is a Christian family man, and despises criminals like this. If there is evidence, he will be prosecuted, if there is not sufficient evidence he will not. Not all accusations bear out to be the truth.
guest

Jamestown, TN

#36 Aug 8, 2010
taz wrote:
alright you tatooed up skank bitch-my son tells me your daughter was pullin trains at a party when she was 14-virgin my ass-only virgin in clay county is an ugly 7 year old-only reason your even bitchin is you think u got a chance for some cash but now that u started mentioning names you are liable for slander-course as stupid as u are you wouldnt know that-best thing u can do is put your daughter on the pill-like your dumbass, stupid people dont need to breed and dam sure shouldnt get pregnant-hope u have a great day-im goin to lake-oh yeah saw you at the marina yesterday-i hope you werent following the Bs-cause i was following you-lot of people have their backs so mind your own-by the way, nice neck tattoo BIMBO
you must be a child molester also,taking up for him,no matter if she layed down and begged him to do it,shes a minor and thats still rape,he should know better,there are to many willing woman of age offering it
taz

Cookeville, TN

#37 Aug 8, 2010
and ur grandma is one of them offering it guest-do you know either family dumbass ? I DO-
Guest

Cookeville, TN

#38 Aug 8, 2010
Who is Chellie and the daughter?
taz

Cookeville, TN

#39 Aug 8, 2010
and since tattoo girl hasnt really said her name i will do it for her-MICHELLE isnt it ? and husband FLOYD ?you opened up a can of shit gettin on here-and i love to stir the turd(that means you chellie)
taz

Cookeville, TN

#40 Aug 8, 2010
ding-ding round two-any takers?
Chellie

Jamestown, TN

#41 Aug 8, 2010
taz wrote:
and since tattoo girl hasnt really said her name i will do it for her-MICHELLE isnt it ? and husband FLOYD ?you opened up a can of shit gettin on here-and i love to stir the turd(that means you chellie)
Rememeber I know who you are too. And Yes Chellie is Michelle maybe you should have known me. PROUDLY MICHELLE AND FLOYD LOVELL. And I live on Holly Creek Rd. I have no need to hide. You didn't open a can of worms. I exposed the truth. Sorry you don't know how to deal with it. You should really try to educate yourself a little better. You might learn real words instead of profanity!
Chellie

Jamestown, TN

#42 Aug 8, 2010
THE POINT TO ALL IS OUR LAWS NEED CHANGE. SEX OFFENSES AGAINST MINORS SHOULDN'T QUALIFY FOR DIVERSION PROGRAMS.
OUR COMMUNITY HAS EVERY RIGHT TO KNOW THAT A SEX OFFENSE HAPPENED IN THEIR BACK YARD. WHOM IT WAS AND WHERE IT WAS. THAT BY NO MEANS IS SLANDER.
AS I SAID MY DAUGHTER RESPECTED AND LOVED THIS FAMILY AND HAD A VERY HARD TIME COMEING FORWARD BECAUSE THE PAIN IT WOULD CAUSE.
HOWEVER RIGHT IS RIGHT AND WRONG IS WRONG.
SHE COULD HAVE LAYED IN FRONT OF HIM NAKED ON HER OWN HE IS 24 YEARS OLD HE SHOULD HAVE COVERED HER UP AND EVEN CALLED ME OR THE POLICE HIMSELF.
IF YOU THINK YOU KNOW ME SO WELL THEN YOU WOULD KNOW I BELONG TO THE SAME MARINA THEY DO. FURTHERMORE I WAS THEIR BEFORE THEY EVEN ARRIVED.
I ALSO HAVE NO NEED TO WATCH MY BACK. I AM IN FEAR OF NOTHING. BECAUSE THE TRUTH IS NEVER SOMETHING TO FEAR.
THIS CASE BY ALL MEANS IS NOT COMPLETE AND YOU ALONG WITH OTHERS WILL SEE THE CHANGES THAT WILL HAPPEN WITH IT.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Celina Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
looking someone Apr 22 angela 4
I need some answers (Sep '08) Apr 20 Curious 15
Are Dutch Craft mattresses good? (Nov '11) Apr 19 very unhappy cust... 21
Pit Bulldogs Apr 19 OldGoat 35
Bradley cross Apr 19 keshia 3
Recycling Place SOLD Apr 19 Clay citizen 10
Family name Arms and/or Glidewell Apr 18 that mathis boy 3
More from around the web

Celina People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

Personal Finance

Mortgages [ See current mortgage rates ]