Murder in Pataskala
brittney

Ashburn, VA

#84 Dec 22, 2012
Jamies Mom wrote:
<quoted text>How r u her cousin? What is ur parents name?
Richard Kelley is my dad's uncle. My dad's name is Danny.
brittney

Ashburn, VA

#85 Dec 22, 2012
Richard Kelley is my dad's uncle. His name is Danny.
grant

Columbus, OH

#86 Jan 21, 2013
i know the sheets familey thay all have mentall problems stay away if you want you and your familey to be safe thay all should be locked up
a friend

Cincinnati, OH

#87 Jan 30, 2013
i found the video that you guys was talking about and i wouldnt watch it. i knew abby and her family and the whole things still breaks my heart
mike wallace

Springfield, NJ

#88 Feb 28, 2013
Just left ohio this morning so many good memories of jamie and abby .miss those times a lot.
S Higgins

Thornville, OH

#89 Mar 2, 2013
Remember this like it was yesterday... I knew Jamie the best, didnt know abby that well. But they neither one deserved this. I hope they are angels above watching over us now.
fyi

Indianapolis, IN

#90 Apr 14, 2013
Unknown wrote:
I remember when they were looking for Abby and Jamie. It was all anyone could talk about in school. I remember one particular day right before we found out that Bobby was involved. Bobby was in PE during the same period that I was and he just sat there and was very quite. We all thought he was upset because he had dated one of the girls.

Melissa.... I hate to tell you this but you this you did not hang out with Bobby and Sonia and smoke cigeretts in the "commons". First of all there really is no "commons" at Watkins. There is a small concrete patio area that had a totem pole. It was right off the main hall where everyone walked. Very rarely did people hang out there. Secondly, Sonia did not go to Watkins. She was from Whitehall.

The "special ed" kid as you called him did not die of heart complications. He was not even special ed. If you knew anything you would know that the guy you are referencing died from epilepsy. He was having close to 100 seizures a week and died in his sleep. He was not a popular kid because of his seizures but he at least deserves to be known as more than a "special ed kid"

So if you are going to make yourself look all special because you went to school and knew these kids then I suggest you do a little bit of homework.
Sonya did go to Watkins. She may have been from Whitehall but she did in fact go to school at Watkins and she was attending Watkins when the murders took place.
alan696969

Wooster, OH

#91 May 13, 2013
. I GREW UP DOWN THE ROAD FROM THESE PLACES THESE EVENTS HAPPENED. I DIDNT PERSONALLY KNOW THE GIRLS BUT MY FRIENDS DID. THE MURDERERS HOUSE IS TWO TRAILERS SITTING IN THE WOODS ON BLACKLICK EASTERN ROAD BEFORE 158. THEY WERE SHOT IN WOODS BEHIND. THEYRE STILL STANDING IF YOU LOOK CLOSELY. THE BODIES WERE TAKEN TO A FEW BARNS ON 158 IF YOU HEAD SOUTH TO BALTIMORE WHERE 158 INTERSECTS WITH BASIL WERE THE ATTEMPT TO BURN THE BODIES BURNT ONE BARN DOWN BUT THE OTHER STILL STANDS AT 158a AND BASIL ROAD
fyi

Morristown, IN

#92 May 13, 2013
alan696969 wrote:
. I GREW UP DOWN THE ROAD FROM THESE PLACES THESE EVENTS HAPPENED. I DIDNT PERSONALLY KNOW THE GIRLS BUT MY FRIENDS DID. THE MURDERERS HOUSE IS TWO TRAILERS SITTING IN THE WOODS ON BLACKLICK EASTERN ROAD BEFORE 158. THEY WERE SHOT IN WOODS BEHIND. THEYRE STILL STANDING IF YOU LOOK CLOSELY. THE BODIES WERE TAKEN TO A FEW BARNS ON 158 IF YOU HEAD SOUTH TO BALTIMORE WHERE 158 INTERSECTS WITH BASIL WERE THE ATTEMPT TO BURN THE BODIES BURNT ONE BARN DOWN BUT THE OTHER STILL STANDS AT 158a AND BASIL ROAD
Yea you are correct. Finally someone knows facts. Thank you
Jamies mom

Charlotte, NC

#93 May 13, 2013
The facts don't change a thing. Let it REST
fyi

Morristown, IN

#94 May 13, 2013
Jamies mom wrote:
The facts don't change a thing. Let it REST
But rumors and "hear say" make it worse.
Wow

United States

#95 May 26, 2013
I graduated from Watkins in 91- and I do remember Sonja Hawkins- she was a freshman. At the time, Watkins wasn't very diverse, so everyone knew who Sonja was. Sad to say, but was true at the time.
What happened to those girls is tragic.
What's worse is that a few people decide to take this thread and turn it into some high school showdown. Grow up- let it go. It's been almost 20 years - It makes you all look pathetic, and it's disrespectful to the memories of those two young kids whose lives were taken by some pretty sick people that are now paying for their crimes.
D-ragon

Tulsa, OK

#96 Jul 5, 2013
Abby poured sugar in boyfriend/ex-boyfriends car,and jamie was just in the wrong place at the wrong time
Anonymous wrote:
Mom Helped Son, 2 Others After Killings, Police Say
October 12, 1994
LANCASTER, OHIO First, Elsie Sheets helped her teen-age son and his two friends get rid of the evidence connecting them to the killings of two schoolmates, police said. Then she made everybody a pizza. All four were charged Tuesday in the shooting deaths of Abby Marie Worrell and Jamie Kay Kelly, both 16. Their bodies were found last week in a burning barn. Sheets, 54, is charged with arson, obstructing justice and other charges. Robert Sheets Jr., 15, and Robert Daniel, 16, are charged with murder. Sonia Hawkins, 19, is charged with complicity to commit murder. Prosecutors have refused to discuss a motive for the slayings.
Dirtyjoe

Columbus, OH

#97 Jul 5, 2013
Abby invited me to go with her to the band party and to hang out afterwards. Lucky for me though, I had other plans that weekend. In some sense, it makes me wonder if the killings would have still happened if I had been with them. Not so much that I would have prevented the gunman, but maybe unnerve them with having to deal with a male and a 3rd person. I sat next to Bobby in health class and we would always BS with each other. After the killings he didn't talk at all. I remember hearing his name in rumors then one day he didn't show for school. That's when they found the bodies beginning of October.
Davis

Dublin, OH

#98 Jul 6, 2013
I was actually in prison for drug trafficking with Elsie sheets and she slept right across from me. Scary and very angry woman. She was always smacking herself really hard and cussing at an imaginary man she called George and I remember waking up to the sound of her cursing and hitting herself hard. They said she had tourets.it's a shame what she did to those poor girls. I knew she was crazy the first night I moved into hale cottage at orw in marysville and seen her acting that way. My heart goes out to the victims and their families.
amber m

Columbus, OH

#99 Aug 8, 2013
Snow Bunny_ wrote:
<quoted text>I remember when that happened.
Two girls from Watkins were lured out by some other kids, and two of the boys took them to a barn, and murdered them...a mother of one of the boys got involved and help bury the girls...it was EXTREMELY sad and very hard to believe.
I googled and googled, but I can't seem to find anything on the crime.
I was 17 when it happened, so it's been a while. I can't remember their names, but I do know the boys went to prison, and so did the mom, and they did recover the girls bodies.
This happened very close to family of mine.
Yes, if anyone can at least remember the girls names..that would help.
Now as an adult, I think of that crime, and MY daughters, and it makes me so very sad:(


Their names are robert sheets and mother elsie sheets both in prison
amber m

Columbus, OH

#100 Aug 8, 2013
grant wrote:
i know the sheets familey thay all have mentall problems stay away if you want you and your familey to be safe thay all should be locked up


Yes mental problems u r right I was I'm marysville orw with mrs sheets and she talks to herself and she hits herself to where she has brusies on her stomach and she does not take meds. She sees people too and will curse at the imagineary people
amy kelley

Haslet, TX

#101 Sep 4, 2013
mike wallace wrote:
Just left ohio this morning so many good memories of jamie and abby .miss those times a lot.
I have only been back a few times since good memories but ones i wish I could forget
Kelly H

Pickerington, OH

#102 Sep 26, 2013
Jamies Mom wrote:
<quoted text>How r u her cousin? What is ur parents name?
Connie
Its Kelly, I have been trying to find you for years, if you get this, please email me at [email protected]
Nina White

Centerton, AR

#104 Sep 29, 2013
Jamies mom wrote:
<quoted text>Amy is fine I can ask her if she would like to hear from u. And alot of you r right some of you have NO IDEA WHAT HAPPENED SO LET IT GO
Connie
I worked with you at Dukes at the time this happened. I think about you often. I recall you got married then I moved and lost contact with you. Wonder about you so much pain. Bless you always.

Nina

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Carroll Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Mark Nicholas Brown (Feb '13) Fri Oreally43062 3
What are they building Jul 18 Fanra5 5
News Chevrolet Malibu Owners: Problems & Solutions (Jun '06) Jul 12 D Canada 2,926
CHC Services Jul 11 Veteran 2
CHC Services Jul 11 Veteran 1
Chey Linston Jul 6 CHEY LINSTEN 3
News Fairfield County sheriff IDs deputy who shot kn... Jul 5 They cannot kill ... 1

Carroll Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Carroll Mortgages