Vander Ark cries during 'Harry Potter...

Vander Ark cries during 'Harry Potter' testimony

There are 3 comments on the WOOD-TV Grand Rapids and Michigan story from Apr 15, 2008, titled Vander Ark cries during 'Harry Potter' testimony. In it, WOOD-TV Grand Rapids and Michigan reports that:

A Harry Potter fan who wants to publish an encyclopedic guide to the wildly popular fantasy novels broke down and cried on the witness stand Tuesday as he faced off in federal court against his idol J.K. ...

Join the discussion below, or Read more at WOOD-TV Grand Rapids and Michigan.


Monroe, LA

#1 Apr 15, 2008
I understand all that stuff about intellectual properties, copyright laws, etc. but with a series as popular as Harry Potter that has the potential for such an expansive universe where new ideas and stuff are constantly being added to it, one similar to the Star Wars universe, what is so wrong with combining all of those ideas into book form so that fans can better understand it all? I don't get why it's okay for people to publish encyclopedias and stuff based on the Star Wars universe, but when it relates to Harry Potter, J.K. Rowling has to get her panties in a bunch when she could have offered an opportunity for Vander Ark to turn his book into a more collaborative effort so that both parties can benefit from it.

United States

#2 Apr 15, 2008
Max Crux

Hollywood, FL

#3 Apr 15, 2008
When Steven Vander Ark's publisher, RDR Books, told him it was okay to publish a printed version of Vander Ark's Harry Potter Lexicon Web site, which is largely derived from work by Harry Potter author J.K. Rowling, Vander Ark accepted that without further question and proceeded with the project. That cavalier attitude is no surprise when one considers he had been trying to market this idea to two other publishers.

When did it become okay to lift someone else's copyrighted material and present it as one's own? That's why,“in the name of scholastic pursuit”, I've made a copy of Vander Ark's Web site to use as my own Web site. Oh, it's okay. I've changed the name of the site and reorganized it a little. My version is called Harry Potter's Maxicon. Different enough, right?


Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Byron Center Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Kyleigh Miles threatened to blow up Michigan hi... May '16 good grief anyhow 3
News Should smoking be allowed again in Michigan bar... May '16 Idea Maker 32
Farmers Disposal in Dorr MI legitimate company? (Nov '11) Mar '16 Owner Farmers Dis... 47
jason lueer (Nov '07) Oct '14 the kids 9
News Great Lakes Water Levels/Ice Update and News (May '14) May '14 Sneaky Pete 2
News Fatal accident on 44th Street in Grandville (Nov '07) Mar '14 Jennifer 21
Review: East West Manual Therapy & SPA (Oct '13) Oct '13 joe schmo 1

Byron Center Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Byron Center Mortgages