Review: Boise Neurology - Michael O'Brien MD

Posted in the Boise Forum

Briana

Boise, ID

#1 Mar 19, 2010
I would never recommend this neurologist. Let me say the only reason my doc even sent me to this guy in the first place is because her first choice -- Dr. River -- was booked out five months and I really needed to see someone. Dr. O'Brien could get me in three days later. After seeing him, I can completely understand why his schedule is so open.

The first thing he told me when I sat down was that he was approaching this from a psychiatric perspective -- that's fine, if I was paying for a psychiatrist! But I paid for a neurology consult and that's what I wanted! I suffer from chronic daily headaches and have for over ten years. He didn't believe me when I told him my headaches were not confined to a single spot, and said if they really hurt as much as I said then I'd know where they were located. When I gave an example of where my headache was at that moment, he leapt to the conclusion that's where they were all the time and diagnosed my headaches as tension-related. He told me the solution would be to simply lose a little weight and get a hobby -- problem solved! Somehow all the doctors I'd seen over the years just hadn't figured it out?! This guy is a total nut-job. He would not listen when I told him that even at my healthiest weight, and when I had the least stress in my life, I was still having these headaches. He was sure he'd found the solution, so no need to look any further. When I asked about possible preventive medications, he mentioned there was one he thought might be effective, but he didn't want to prescribe it for me. And regarding the pain medications I was currently taking -- also known as the only things that were currently making it possible for me to function -- he said to go ahead and stop taking those cold turkey, because that plan to lose weight and get a hobby was obviously iron-clad, and everyone knows that losing weight happens overnight, right? So clearly that would kick in immediately, and I'd be able to keep working and living without interruption.

Neurologists are supposed to use actual diagnostic means to get to the root of your problem -- blood work, MRIs, etc.-- not just pretending they have a psychiatric degree. This guy even went so far as to speculate about why I was sitting with my legs crossed a particular way and how I phrased responses to questions. After ten minutes, I felt incredibly uncomfortable and knew that he was going to criticize every answer that came out of my mouth. It felt like I was being interrogated!

Save yourself the time and money and find another neurologist.
Mike

Portland, OR

#2 Mar 19, 2010
Sorry you had such a bad experience. keep taking your meds book a time for Dr River and pray for a cancellation. Good luck and don't give up!
Mark

Portland, OR

#3 Mar 29, 2014
In contrast, I had a wonderful experience with Dr. O'Brien. I had had a stroke and I was sent to him to determine if I had any permanent nerve damage. He went through all the cranial nerves, one at a time. Some of the exercises I could do, some I could not. I spent 2.5 hours with him. He told me things about my body that my own Internist had missed. Like a heart Murmur. One of the things I really liked about him is he faced me and talked to me. The Internist always faces the computer and types, in otherwords he wasn't watching me.
Dr. O'Brien is semi retired doing evaluations for Social Security, Insurance Companies and other Doctors. I found him to be outstanding. I wish he was still in a full time practice, I would like to be able to have him look over my health records periodically to find out what the Internists are missing.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Boise Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Boise Immigration Rally Draws Hundreds, Call fo... (May '13) Apr 22 The real zeke 196
Suspect in Custody After Six Hour Standoff in N... Apr 22 mother of Carlos 1
We Want IN-n-OUT Burgers To Build In Idaho (Apr '09) Apr 20 Klena78 40
Review: Le Nails (May '10) Apr 17 Laura johnson 18
Debate: Health Care - Kuna, ID (Oct '09) Apr 15 The real zeke 4
Review: Aldape Sprinkler Service (Mar '13) Apr 14 TA of Boise 13
News Are Californians The Root Of Idaho's Evils? (May '06) Apr 10 The real zeke 3,206
More from around the web

Boise People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

Personal Finance

Mortgages [ See current mortgage rates ]