Judged:
1
1
1
Really?Pahoran said "You attributed something called an "eternal rock theory" to Joseph Smith. Your attribution was false"
well here is another account of Joseph Smith's eternal rock theory:
Does it actually say anything about eternal rocks?
Let's see.
I will note, first of all, that Wikipedia is not an LDS source."The earth's creation, according to Mormon scripture, was not ex nihilo, but organized from existing matter. " [Snip extraneous stuff.]
this is from this site:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mormon_cosmology
Valid sources for LDS doctrine are, well, LDS sources. Wikipedia is not one of them.
That aside, can you please explain how you imagine that passage supports any "eternal rock theory?"
It says nothing about rocks. It only talks about *matter*.
Matter is not rocks, although rocks are matter.
But you are intelligent enough to realise that, aren't you?
And therefore you are intelligent enough to realise that the point at issue is *not* whether Joseph taught that the universe was organised from pre-existing matter; I freely and cheerfully affirm that he did teach it.
The point at issue is whether your phrase "eternal rock theory" is an accurate, honest description of Joseph's teaching, or a derisive, misleading distortion.
And you know what?
*Every single source* you have cited becomes one more witness *against* you.
Joseph Smith said *nothing* about "eternal rocks*. If he had, you would have found a source by now.
Why do you insist upon these lies, smurf boy? The Church continues to teach its doctrine, including the doctrine that the creation was not _ex nihilo_. And you, an atheist, thinks this is "insanity?"this can also be confirmed by grabbing a copy of earlier works of the mormons at yard sales and thrift shops. The church is busy trying to destroy all the evidence that points towards their insanity while feverishly lying and attacking hatefully anyone who tries to bring it to the public's attention.
I see.
So you are changing the subject.Well, Pahoran, your insane campaign is not going to work! I am not alone in recognizing the evil in your church and will continue to post whatever I can to help people see the insane danger your organization represents to the spiritual growth of Humanity!
Here is a short text file on dismantling the horrible edifice of the Patriarchal Religious Military Industrial Complex of which the LDS is a prominent player:
http://grandpasmurf9520.wordpress.com/2009/07...
To your own insane conspiracy theory.
Oh well.
Regards,
Pahoran






