Best Pizza in Bellefontaine

Best Pizza in Bellefontaine

Created by HerpDerp on Apr 10, 2012

788 votes

Click on an option to vote

B-Town Pizza

Vicario's

Padrone's

Ron's

Michael's

Downtown 600

Pizza Planet

Fat Boys

Donatos

Other (Specify Below)

First Prev
of 3
Next Last
HerpDerp

Bellefontaine, OH

#1 Apr 10, 2012
Vote & discuss.

I've been getting Padrone's a lot lately. Good stuff, good price. Reminds me a little of Papa John's (which I miss).
jon simon

West Mansfield, OH

#2 Apr 10, 2012
speedway..........Baby!
lakerhater

United States

#3 Apr 10, 2012
Fatboys
Ethel

Fredericktown, OH

#4 Apr 10, 2012
Not in Bellefontaine, but my favorite has always been Cassano's.
depends

Bedford, OH

#5 Apr 10, 2012
Bellefontaine has different varieties of pizza that are mostly all pretty good. Depends on the day on which I prefer. I was not impressed with 600 the one time I went. I will have to give it one more try to be certain.
Ethel

Fredericktown, OH

#6 Apr 10, 2012
depends wrote:
Bellefontaine has different varieties of pizza that are mostly all pretty good. Depends on the day on which I prefer. I was not impressed with 600 the one time I went. I will have to give it one more try to be certain.
I agree. I had heard it was great, but I thought it was just OK. Now, those garlic knots they have are really good.
Olivier

Ada, OH

#7 Apr 10, 2012
Depends when you go.

You wait 45 minutes to be seated and another 30 minutes for your food. By the time I'm done eating I need another depends.
LoCo

Potosi, MO

#8 Apr 10, 2012
Padrones, Ron's, donatos, 600, vicarios!!! Bellefontaine has plenty of good pizza options!! That's my favorites!!
pizza

Bellefontaine, OH

#9 Apr 10, 2012
Pizza is a matter of taste. I like one place and my wife likes another. I like the greasy pan pizza from Pizza Hut and she only likes the thin crust. We both like Fat Boys. They are consistent. Michael's taco pizza is always great. Haven't tried 600 so we don't know. Vicarrio's is consistent too. We love the sweet sauce when it is pep and onions. They have great subs too. I don't like Dominoes pizza at all but their subs are great. We haven't tried Predrone's so we don't know about it. I love Donato's but the heartburn after is too much for me. I hated Papa John's except the Spinach Alfredo. The point is that we all have different tastes just like beer. Some like Bud products, some like Miller products or whatever. The great thing is that we have a lot to chose from here.
rumors

Cleveland, OH

#10 Apr 11, 2012
ron's was my favorite until 600 came to town.
I have not had ron's for awhile so I had one last weekend and it was not very good. Greasy and not as much cheese as they used to give. I was disappointed.

“Abolish political parties!”

Since: Aug 10

Bellefontaine, Ohio

#11 Apr 11, 2012
Fat Boys!!! And Michael's is good too.
OLIVIER IS A DIPSHlT

Marysville, OH

#12 Apr 11, 2012
Logan County Mom has the best pie in town!
OLIVIER IS A DIPSHlT

Bucyrus, OH

#13 Apr 11, 2012
Poop pie yummy
Curious

Ashley, OH

#14 Apr 11, 2012
Michaels Pizza has the best Taco Pizza in Logan county. Nobody can beat it. But I Like Donatoes thin crust pizza the best.
HerpDerp

Bellefontaine, OH

#15 Apr 12, 2012
LOL! How did B-Town Pizza go from 0 votes to 14 and 4th place overnight?

Obviously the owner thinks their pizza is so good they cleared the cookies to get it higher in the poll.
AyMon

Bellefontaine, OH

#16 Apr 12, 2012
I don't know about the pizza, but I do know the owner of Rons Pizza is a Hottie!
Ethel

Cardington, OH

#17 Apr 12, 2012
Curious wrote:
Michaels Pizza has the best Taco Pizza in Logan county. Nobody can beat it. But I Like Donatoes thin crust pizza the best.
I used to think Michaels had the best taco pizza until a friend recommended I try Firehouse in Zanesfield. It was even better. This was several years ago, so I am not sure they are still THAT good, but I was very impressed.
Pie eater

United States

#18 Apr 12, 2012
Vicarios hasgreat pizza but btown pizza has killer subs
Uuhh

Mount Gilead, OH

#19 Apr 12, 2012
600 sucks

“Abolish political parties!”

Since: Aug 10

Bellefontaine, Ohio

#20 Apr 13, 2012
Vote Fat Boys!!!

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 3
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Bellefontaine Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
wood forest bank at walmart bellefontaine ohio (Jan '15) 4 hr Brian Burchiel 14
Sherry Barton (Jul '09) 4 hr Brian Burchiel 38
Roypublicans 11 hr Brian Burchiel 5
Trump is yours.......Deal with it! (Jan '17) 12 hr Mein Trumpf 2,261
IL Superintendent Patrick O'Donnell offered sw... 13 hr American Greed 7
Jim Jordan's favorite former aide Wes Goodman w... 16 hr caiaphas 20
Perverts in Government Mon Brian Burchiel 30

Bellefontaine Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Bellefontaine Mortgages