Judge Shirley Carlisle Brown
Posted in the Asheville Forum
#1 Apr 13, 2010
[Published by me in usenet in 2002]
Asheville, North Carolina is an arcadian town nestled among the highest
mountains east of the Mississippi. On a sunny day the youth of the new age
crowd into the streets. The cafes and restaurants bustle with commerce and
chatter of playful children. A peregrine falcon has taken up residence in
clerestory of Asheville's 18-story courthouse, a perfect vantage for survey
the city's plump pigeons. If you see a flock of pigeons performing aerial
maneuvers, like heading north then abruptly turning south, squint your eyes
most likely you will see the swift little raptor selecting his prey and
striking it from midair.
But there is other predation worthy of note in the town that was made famous
Altamont in the great novels of Thomas Wolfe.
Asheville has always had its share, more than its share, of rogue
politicians----sheriffs who enriched themselves with payoffs; detectives who
gazed upon the women's section of the jail as a ripe source of sexual
pleasure; city fathers who lulled, or threatened, the citizenry into
their chicanes; and judges who, owing to some vicious mole of nature in
Shirley Carlisle came to Asheville after unrewarding years officially
representing the inmates of John Umpstead Memorial Hospital, an institution
the mentally ill. She took a position as an assistant prosecutor with
Attorney Ron Brown. Before long the defense attorneys began to grumble that
she was Brown's most aggressive prosecutor. There was talk that she and
had a "thing" going, but it soon fizzled and she married Brown's
Bob, whom Brown had specially selected as suitable for the DA's office from
There were certain cringings when she became judge. These fears in the
courthouse and in the legal community at large, from those aware of an
overzealous prosecutor, had not emerged as hysteria, but as perfectly
expectations. She never took off her mantle as prosecutor before she donned
her black robe. Many civil libertarians would say that it may not be such a
good idea to elevate so many prosecutors to the judiciary.
She now faces re-election, two days away, and a credentialed challenger. A
political advertisement in the town's only newspaper, a member of the
conglomerate, states that Shirley C. Brown in effect has sullied her office
with her insolence, arrogance, and violations of the rule of law.
A few of her violations are as follows:
1. She tried an unfortunate criminal defendant when she knew that the
defendant's attorney was in a trial in federal court. By written rule in
General Statutes she was required to yield to the federal court's
until the defendant's attorney was released. Facts are that she went ahead
with the trial, in spite of a call by the federal judge to explain to her
defendant's attorney was occupied in his court.
2. Eight out of eight civil cases she tried were overturned in the
courts, two of them for abuse of judicial discretion.
#2 Apr 13, 2010
You can read the rest of it here, as I am sure she has. That's the reason why she should not be sitting in judgment over any matter in which I am a party, and should recuse herself:
3. The judge sat on numerous cases and refused to sign judgments and orders
them; some of the delays were as long as a year, and were without any
justification. Attorneys and their parties at court are well aware of the
torment of having to wait for the protracted delay in the entry of judgments
and orders. Attorneys, who have to bear the repeated, angry complaints of
their clients awaiting closure of their important matters, can tell you how
disruptive it is to have to explain daily to them, their family, and
that the judge refuses to act. Often, due to no fault of their own,
are fired, taking the blame for the wrongful delay of an abusive judge.
Justice delayed is justice denied.
4. In outrageous violation of the canons of judicial ethics, she swore
in as a witness and testified in a contempt case over which she presided as
judge, both of the facts and the law.
In North Carolina the only body for the oversight of the judiciary, other
the electorate, is the Judicial Standards Commission, which distinguishes
itself by its refusal to act. The explanation for this phenomenon is that
JSC has historically embraced the tenet that the judiciary is an
sovereignty and that only the most egregious defalcations would be
Certain liberties of the masses, it was thought, were expendible in the
preservation of order. Therefore, the organized bar were trained, from wet
ears on up, that a complaint filed with the Judicial Standards Commission
an exercise in futility. Even worse than that, horrid sanctions would
the lawyer who was brave and indiscreet enough to invoke the majesty of the
Judicial Standards Commission, where whistleblowers were considered, the
as everywhere else, to be pesky vermin.
Several years ago the secretive JSC defrocked a judge who used his robes as
tool to indulge his lust for the flesh of unwilling females. It was a good
time to get rid of him since he was grandfathered in as one of those
on the bench who did not have a degree in law. Recently the JSC
rid the bench of Susan Renfer, whose wily aberrations in the courtroom
those of Shirley Carlisle Brown.
Tuesday next, the official record of arrogance and misbehavior of Judge
Carlisle Brown will come before the voters of Buncombe County, to be weighed
the balance with what good she has done.
#3 Apr 13, 2010
Since it is your opinion, I will make sure to vote for her! Your word doesn't carry too much weight around here.
#4 Apr 14, 2010
Sounds like things did not go well for "Buncy" yesterday in court. If Buncy don't like Judge Brown, then she sure has my vote.
#5 Apr 14, 2010
Well, lookie here. Buncy thinks he is Thomas Wolf.
His next installment will be; "You can't practice law again.
Since: Feb 10
#6 Apr 14, 2010
Shirley is a sadist. She needs to be removed next election cycle.
#7 Apr 14, 2010
LOL...but seriously, what was Buncy in court about yesterday?
#8 Apr 14, 2010
Let's hope it's about relentless post stalking, character assassinations, threatening, and outting of real life personal names and info and even those lies but posted as real information such as
It would be so nice to post on here again for some of us with out all the harassing and promises of visits to our homes and the personal vendettas of finding every scrap of information about posters to plant here on the internet.
Yes that would be real nice for someone to learn they cannot control the thoughts or postings of others by instilling fear for their safety or anonymity.
#11 Apr 14, 2010
As far as I can tell it was Hartsock that went to court yesterday with Buncy as the "victim." So far, I see no continuance on it or charges brought against Buncy. Doubt that Buncy started this post.
I agree that it would be nice to post here again without all that nonsense. Just don't see that happening. Hope you are doing well Ms. MsMe.
#13 Apr 14, 2010
Buncy says he DID start this thread.
Since: Feb 10
#15 Apr 14, 2010
Shirley Brown is a bitch and should not be on the bench. Whoa to any of you who get a speeding ticket and end up getting this Marquis De Sade worshipper.
#16 Apr 14, 2010
Hey! doing good, took a break from here for a while during my busy season. lol
This thread looks to me like a certain lawyer got a Judge he can't bullsmitt or have in his address book so is trying to set up a reason for this Judge to remove themselves from his case whatever it may be.
Regardless it looks like things are not going as well for him as he wants and that's always a reason to smile for me.:-D
#17 Apr 14, 2010
What goes around comes around, LOL! Didn't take long at all for this place to quiet down with him gone! Does anyone know what really happened?
#18 Apr 14, 2010
Buncy and Larry were remanded to after-school suspension until they both grow up.
Since: Feb 10
#19 Apr 14, 2010
Seriously, Shirley Brown is a sadistic bitch. Just hope you never come up before this witch. She treats traffic tickets like they are crimes.
“ Mr. Cougar”
Since: Mar 07
#20 Apr 14, 2010
Hooker loves Judge Brown.
Tarawa Terrace, NC
#21 Apr 14, 2010
have you had biblical knowledge of ron and bob brown's squeeze, hooka?????
Tarawa Terrace, NC
#22 Apr 14, 2010
Have you noticed the absence of vulgar references and insults toward females, aggrandized self-important statements, and zero use of the "N" word? How quickly some forget.
#23 Apr 14, 2010
Traffic tickets are crimes.
Since: Feb 10
#24 Apr 14, 2010
Traffic tickets are NOT crimes.They are infractions. Shirley is the typical hardass who rules over small things in a hanging judge way. They should put her up where the criminals come in. That's where the hardass is needed.
Add your comments below
|It's the Darwin crowd that lacks the facts in e... (Mar '09)||4 min||Endofdays||167,079|
|Crooked City Manager, Gary Jackson, Says He's R...||1 hr||Local Born Raised||8|
|ABE LINCOLN Was A WHITE SUPREMACIST RACIST||1 hr||Moonshine Mill||31|
|Despite arrest, police beating shows technology...||5 hr||Queen Esther Lizzy||4|
|Wanda Greene||Fri||DonutJackie Van D...||4|
|Hillary Clinton is a career criminal! (Sep '16)||Mar 14||Liberal Democrat ...||26|
|White Police Officer Resigns After Video Shows ...||Mar 14||FireFellow44||44|
Find what you want!
Search Asheville Forum Now
Copyright © 2018 Topix LLC