Women Blamed for Friend's Drinking De...

Women Blamed for Friend's Drinking Death Plead Guilty

There are 16 comments on the WJW Fox 8 Cleveland story from Feb 11, 2010, titled Women Blamed for Friend's Drinking Death Plead Guilty. In it, WJW Fox 8 Cleveland reports that:

After returning home to Alliance, Carri went out drinking one night last February with her sister, Misty Goodwin, and a family friend, Lori Osterland.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at WJW Fox 8 Cleveland.

I understand

Erie, PA

#1 Feb 12, 2010
this mothers pain, but all 3 were at fault here. Yes, the girl who died shares the blame.

Since: Dec 09

United States

#2 Feb 12, 2010
Strap yourselves in, this forum is about to get wild. Remember the last story on this?

Since: Nov 09

Location hidden

#3 Feb 12, 2010
I was thinking the same thing. I will stay out of it this time.
Ann Porter

Cleveland, OH

#5 Feb 12, 2010
A similar situtation happened to me at a bar. My husband and I were with one of my friends. We out drank him, and he left about a half an hour before us. Found out the next day that he slept for 2-3 hours in the parking lot at the bar. Now, whose fault was that, ours? If he killed someone or got arrested for DUI, was that our fault? I'm sorry, but sometimes the "victim" needs to take blame for his/her own actions. That is all.
Jack

Akron, OH

#6 Feb 12, 2010
It takes a village to get somebody this drunk. They may be in for a tough time because if they furnished the alcohol, the manslaughter is a direct consequence. Can't separate the two even without the additional act of leaving her in the car. Adios.
Just Me

Warren, OH

#7 Feb 12, 2010
DSGRL wrote:
Carri got what she deserved, plain and simple.
No one deserves to die! You really either need to get a reality check or you need to just shut the F up!
DSGRL

Cleveland, OH

#8 Feb 12, 2010
pistoff wrote:
Strap yourselves in, this forum is about to get wild. Remember the last story on this?
LOL.....
Vikki

United States

#9 Feb 12, 2010
Jack wrote:
It takes a village to get somebody this drunk. They may be in for a tough time because if they furnished the alcohol, the manslaughter is a direct consequence. Can't separate the two even without the additional act of leaving her in the car. Adios.
A village? Did they not say she had a drinking problem? I'm sure she enjoyed drinking her brains out and needed a break and went to the car. Yes, her friend and sister should have a least checked on her. They are all at fault here.
Midnight

Cleveland, OH

#10 Feb 12, 2010
I think it's just sad that the mother got 90 days for assulting the dumb ***** that aided in the death of her daughter but the dumb ***** only got 6 months. WTF? Something is SERIOUSLY wrong with our justice system.
Just Me

Warren, OH

#11 Feb 12, 2010
carri did not drink before being raped and beat while in the usmc! she had ptsd from being raped in service!!!!! they got away with it!!!!have you ever heard of an alcoholic completing 3 months of marine corps bootcamp at parris island!!!!!!!being an expert shot to boot! the only one in her platoon!!! I only wish that the reporter that i told this to on the phone yesterday would have done his job, and tell the truth about what really happened!!!! the proof is in her medical records, and journals she wrote, that describe the rapes and how the marine corps threatened more of the same, if she didn't do what they said, including being forced to take zoloft, which is widely known to cause suicidal tendencys!carri'sdad!!!!!!

This was written by carri's father in the other forum that is following this story. According to him the report given on the news was false. The reporter twisted the father's words. Dont listen to everything you hear on TV!
wish i knew

Fairview, PA

#12 Feb 12, 2010
carri did not drink before being raped twice in the usmc, the rapist also beat her!!!!!did you ever here of a person completing 3 months of marine corps boot camp at parris island, an also being a supposed alcoholic?! she was the only expert shot in her platoon!! i have communicated with several people she served with and none of them said she drank! go figure! if anyone cares for the truth look up burke oneil law firm out of washington dc, they have started a class action civil lawsuit in carri goodwins behalf, against the fine usmc! please punch in carri memorial on youtube to see what my daughter was like prier to being beat and raped by an nco she worked with!!!!!! carri's dad>
jim

United States

#13 Feb 12, 2010
Midnight wrote:
I think it's just sad that the mother got 90 days for assulting the dumb ***** that aided in the death of her daughter but the dumb ***** only got 6 months.****? Something is SERIOUSLY wrong with our justice system.
They are two different charges apples and oranges, I am not saying the mother was not anger, I would be anger at someone that was involved with my child’s death, however, my anger or hers in this case does not justifies attacking someone. Maybe it should I did not see, read or hear of mom also beating her own child for her involvement.
Madison

Perry, OH

#14 Feb 12, 2010
Sorry, but Carrie is old enough for her own actions. By looking @ the video, her mother looks ruff so why would Carrie know any different.
She was old enough to join the service.
Quest

Ashland, OH

#15 Feb 12, 2010
It is a tragedy, but they were all out drinking so not just one or two of them should be held accountable, all three should. If the situation was reversed and one of the other girls had died then would the family be fighting so hard to keep her out of prison? Of course!
gary noling

Fairview, PA

#16 Feb 12, 2010
yea madison can almost read, what a losser, and by the way it's CARRI!!!
okim65

Lake Jackson, TX

#17 Feb 13, 2010

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Alliance Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Kevin Nicholson (Sep '13) Aug 28 ShadyAf 3
old friends (Grubb) (Jan '15) Aug 28 ShadyAf 2
News Alliance men charged in meth sales Aug 28 ShadyAf 1
News Stefani Schaefer (Oct '09) Aug '17 Soul for GOD 62
Election Who do you support for County Auditor in Ohio (... (Oct '10) Mar '17 Randy Miller 7
Excessive Sebring Water Bills (Feb '17) Feb '17 JLB 1
Shirley Vance from Coalton Ohio (Oct '16) Oct '16 Slowlicker 4 you 2

Alliance Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Alliance Mortgages