“reign in blood”

Since: May 09

Braidwood, IL

#1 Jul 21, 2014
DEAR AMY: Seven years ago my father was arrested for having sex with a 16-year-old girl. He was sent to prison for seven years and will be released in about a month.

No one (including my family and me) has had any contact with him since his arrest. No one knows the reasons why he did what he did.

My mother, sister and brother have decided to have nothing to do with him. My husband is encouraging me to do the same.

I still have feelings for him; he was a very loving father to me and never did anything inappropriate with my sister or me.

Even if I can forgive him my husband and family will most likely disown me if I contact him. What would you suggest?-- Forgiving Daughter

DEAR FORGIVING: The kindest assumption is that these family members worry that you are at risk (emotionally, at least) if you are in touch with your father.

The more likely assumption is also more complicated: Your family members don't want to have anything to do with him and would like to punish you for having a more forgiving and nuanced reaction to your father because this calls their judgment into question.

Your mother and siblings are on one side of this equation. Your husband, however, is the person who should hold your hand through this. He should not threaten to disown you but should be willing to support you through your decision-making process. Your father is a convicted sex offender. Please understand that your husband has reason to be worried, confused and protective.

At the end of the day, other people cannot tell you what relationships to have. If you are determined to pursue this, you should do so knowing that you have every right -- but you might be quite lonely doing so. Be aware, also, that the process of reconciliation is a crooked path. It can be extremely painful and may not end in a tidy resolution, but in more heartache. I think you are brave to try.

DEAR AMY: My 33-year-old daughter lives abroad with her boyfriend.

Until recently, they were looking for rings, but she met a married guy (with two children), and she has suddenly found her soul mate!

Amy, her boyfriend is the sweetest guy in the world. He is very caring and in love with her.

I am absolutely devastated that she has no regard for anyone else's feelings. She says they are just friends, but she no longer wants to get engaged.

She also says that if he told her that he would leave his wife, she would marry him in a heartbeat.

She is asking for my advice. The advice I gave her is to stay away from fire so she would not get burned. I have also asked her to move back to the U.S., find a job and then find herself -- before she looks for love.

What do you think?-- Distraught Mother!

DEAR DISTRAUGHT: You gave your daughter sound and practical advice.

Do not expect her to follow it.

This sounds like one of those situations where the heart wants what it wants. Under these circumstances, the head, unfortunately, seldom cooperates.

It is very disappointing to see the child you raised embroiled in a domestic mess of her own creation; the good news is that she seems to be honest and forthcoming with you. Her actions (and that of the married man) could cause extreme disruption in the lives of several people. This is a very unfortunate situation and she has it within her power to effect a different outcome.

DEAR AMY: Please tell "Distraught" to run like the wind from the freeloader guy she is considering marrying.

My son-in-law is 42 years old and still freeloading. Work is a foreign concept to him. Distraught will come to resent his lack of motivation while she works her tail off. He will be a horrible example for any children they might have.

I couldn't keep my daughter from marrying, but I hope Distraught doesn't make the same mistake.-- Voice of Experience

DEAR VOICE: I agree that the lack of motivation is a real red flag.

“reign in blood”

Since: May 09

United States

#2 Jul 21, 2014
1- I doubt you're family will disown you and your husband should support you. You always let other people run your life?

2- you can't live her life for her. You've given your advice, it's up to her to decide to follow it

Marina, CA

#3 Jul 21, 2014
LW1: Your family has taken a very hard line and you are more balanced. Your father is a flawed human being who used very poor judgment, committed a crime, and was incarcerated for it. Some might say that he has paid his debt to society. You remember that he was a good father to you growing up and you want to honor him for that. He will most likely have a hard time adjusting to life on the outside again, and it would be good if his family could offer some emotional support. The problem is that you didn’t keep in touch with him when he was incarcerated. So he may or may not be open to reconciliation now. I also think you are brave to try, and I think you should.

LW2: You gave your daughter great advice and she’s a fool if she doesn’t take it. But I agree w/Amy that she probably will not. Going forward, if she asks for more advice, you just tell her,“You already know how I feel about this” and just listen to her. It’s tough to watch people go down this path.


“Where is Everyone?”

Since: Jul 12

Location hidden

#4 Jul 21, 2014
L1: Do what you feel is right. That is the only advice I could give. Personally, could not be the one to try to be a part of his life, though.

L2: She's definitely not thinking. All you could do is what this LW did and let the pieces fall where they may. Some have to learn from experience.

L3: I don't know what letter this is about.

Chicago, IL

#5 Jul 21, 2014
Toj wrote:
L2: She's definitely not thinking. All you could do is what this LW did and let the pieces fall where they may. Some have to learn from experience.
Oh, she's thinking all right. Just not with her head. The fact that she seems to have no qualms about hoping to break up a marriage where two (presumably young) children are involved says a lot about her, none of it good. With any luck, her "soulmate" will end the friendship before it becomes anything more. But she should def. not get engaged to her current boyfriend; sounds like he deserves a lot better.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Chicago Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News BARACK OBAMA BIRTH CERTIFICATE: Suit contesting... (Jan '09) 13 min tuffet 239,291
News Barack Obama, our next President (Nov '08) 49 min Agents of Corruption 1,508,086
Ron Kessler's observations about Presidents etc. 59 min Good info 2
Obama has LEAK under sink. 1 hr Undersink Obumbler 34
This doesn't seem fair to me. 1 hr Fascists R Star 8
{keep A word drop A word} (Oct '11) 3 hr They cannot kill ... 10,491
Topix Chitown Regulars (Aug '09) 4 hr Mister Tonka 105,049

Chicago Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Chicago Mortgages