Halton courts slipping into crisis si...

Halton courts slipping into crisis situation: Judge

Posted in the Georgetown Forum


North Bay, Canada

#1 Nov 17, 2012
Halton Region’s courthouses are “slipping further into a crisis situation” because of growing demands and limited resources, says an Ontario Court judge.

Justice Stephen Brown made the statement in a written decision released last month in which he stayed charges against a man accused of impaired driving because of too many delays in court.

Antonio Papandrea arrived at the Burlington courthouse May 24 prepared for his trial. He and his lawyer, Jonathan Rosenthal, waited all morning only to find out shortly before 1 p.m. there was no way a judge could hear the case that day.

By September the case was still on hold, so Rosenthal argued the many months spent waiting for trial since Papandrea’s June 2011 arrest were just too long. By the time the case was supposed to have resumed, on Oct. 19, it would have been 15 months and 20 days.

Brown found the delays to be unreasonable and caused Papandrea to suffer “financial and emotional prejudice.”

He said in his decision that the need for shortage of judicial resources and court space to deal with “explosive growth” in the region is “leading to a breaking point.”

The situation is getting worse, even though colleagues are working hard on weekends, evenings and over vacation time, he wrote.

The argument that significant court delays violate a person’s Charter rights has been around since a Supreme Court of Canada decision in 1990. But experts warn the issue is set to become a major problem in many busy courts across Ontario.

Rosenthal, a criminal defence lawyer based in Toronto, said under-resourced and overwhelmed courthouses are a growing problem. He anticipates more and more charges will be stayed or withdrawn because of unreasonable delays.

“The backlog is easy to fix; it’s just a matter of resources,” he said.

Halton has two courts that deal with matters before the Ontario Court of Justice — in Burlington and Milton. Some 30 kilometres separate these courthouses, making transfers difficult or impossible, Brown said in his decision.

The region has seen a 13 per cent increase in new cases and a 17 per cent increase in hearings since 2006. But it has also had a 22 per cent increase in cases withdrawn or stayed during that time, with 11,598 cases disposed of in the 2010-2011 year.

The Ministry of the Attorney General does not keep statistics about why cases are dropped, said spokesperson Brendan Crawley in an email.

“The causes of delay are complex and inter-related,” he said, adding minimizing those delays requires partnerships across the justice system, including police, judges, prosecutors and defence lawyers.

“The ministry works closely with the judiciary to ensure that court locations are effectively resourced, including consulting with the Ontario Court of Justice to review the status of the judicial complement,” Crawley said.

Most criminal cases are dealt with in Ontario court; only the most serious of cases go to Superior Court.

There are seven provincial judges dealing with these cases, plus family court, which has also had 25 per cent increase in cases heard since 2006.

This is the same number of judges the region has had since 2004, Brown said in his decision.

The problem is compounded by the fact Halton Region is one of the fastest growing areas in the province, with a population of 518,660 in 2011 compared with just 390,235 in 2001.

John Hale, a criminal defence lawyer and part-time lecturer at Carleton University and the University of Ottawa, said the high incidence of cases being dismissed because of delays — a significant problem in the early 1990s — is creeping back up again, particularly in growing urban areas.

He estimates there will be a 10 to 20 per cent increase in cases withdrawn or stayed in the next few years.

It’s a complicated problem: Populations are growing, and while crime rates remain stagnant or are declining, criminal charges are increasing, he said.

Where prosecutors once had discretion

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Georgetown Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Sophisticated operation (Sep '10) 20 hr Fentanyl in local... 2
Agricultural Community Meeting tonight Pineview... (Nov '08) 20 hr Mac 49
Senior defrauded of $7,500 in furnace repair scam (Apr '11) 20 hr R U safe eh 3
News Police searching for suspect after stabbing and... 20 hr R U safe eh 1
News Inside The Herald - If a community is only wort... (Jan '08) Mon why Herald MIA 56
Candidates were MIA in Norval NO OLD HOMERS (Nov '10) Mon dEBATES MIA 2 4
News Georgetown District High School to host fourth ... Mon Tazer vs shot eh 19
More from around the web