Beware of police diversity units that...

Beware of police diversity units that threaten rabbis

Posted in the Georgetown Forum


North Bay, Canada

#1 May 5, 2013
Beware of police diversity units that threaten rabbis

by Brian Lilley

In Canada you have free speech — at least until the authorities say you don’t — and this week one such authority used his power to trample all over that fundamental freedom.

A talk at a synagogue just north of Toronto had to be moved after a member of the “diversity unit” of the York Regional Police Force essentially threatened the rabbi in charge. The synagogue had been rented by a group called the Jewish Defence League so they could host free-speech advocate and anti-jihadist Pamela Geller.

Insp. Ricky Veerappan, one of York Region’s finest, decided he didn’t like what Geller might say so he paid a visit to Rabbi Mendel Kaplan of the Chabad Flamingo synagogue.

Kaplan is one of the chaplains of the York Regional Police, and Veerappan made it clear that if Geller appeared at the synagogue then Kaplan would lose his position.

Rabbi Kaplan’s response should have been to show Veerappan the door and remind the inspector that we live in a free country and until someone breaks the law they are innocent.

Unfortunately, he did not. He understood the implied threat and told the event organizers that the booking was cancelled.

“Some of the stuff that

Ms. Geller speaks about runs contrary to the values of York Regional Police and the work we do in engaging our communities,” Veerappan told QMI Agency.

Quite frankly inspector, you offend me but you are still in your job.

Police are supposed to enforce laws, not enforce unwritten and vague “values” of the community.

Veerappan told QMI Agency some members of the Muslim community complained to him that Geller would be speaking and he stepped in.

What Veerappan has done is assume Geller will commit a crime and acted to make sure she could not do that.

It’s not like she was planning a terrorist attack that had to be stopped, she was simply going to speak about radical Islam and jihad.

Fortunately for free speech, the organizers have found a new venue, the Toronto Zionist Centre — the talk will go on albeit outside of the jurisdiction of York Region’s values enforcers.

That a police officer threatened a rabbi if he did not cancel an event with a speaker the cop did not like should outrage everyone.

Yet outside of several blogs and some limited media coverage, such as QMI Agency and Sun News Network, the media is silent.

My friend Salim Mansur wrote to York Region Police Chief Eric Jolliffe to demand better.

Mansur started off by telling the chief that he was a Muslim and a professor of political science at the University of Western Ontario.

“I am appalled that in this day and age we continue to hear regularly how the liberal democratic tradition of Canada and the West is being systematically shredded by institutions sworn to protect it,” Mansur wrote.

And he’s right.

It’s shocking that Prof. Mansur needs to school a police chief in Canada about freedom of speech, but clearly it needs to be done.

From the recent Whatcott decision at the Supreme Court (it said even speech that is true can be hate speech) to vexatious complaints about values, free speech is under attack in Canada. If we don’t stand up and defend it, we’re going to lose it

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Georgetown Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Residents fears unique scout camp could close j... (Jun '08) 46 min meanwhile 4
Acton Scout building searched by OPP in murder ... (Oct '13) 50 min meanwhile 3
Ontario updates condo Act, lowers cost of dispu... (May '15) 51 min only now 5
News Senior volunteers are feted (Apr '12) 54 min meanwhile 6
News Reading Club signup begins (Jun '09) 5 hr Kids 2day eh 3
OLD Russ (Jun '09) 5 hr Tony 2
Ted Kennedy: Tragedy, scandal and redemption (Aug '09) 5 hr Tony Gambino inte... 3
More from around the web