Top Ohio Oil & Gas Regulator Lauds St...

Top Ohio Oil & Gas Regulator Lauds State Regulation

Posted in the Natural Gas Forum

Anne Carto

Aurora, OH

#1 Apr 19, 2013
This week, Rick Simmers, Chief of the Ohio Department of Natural Resources — Division of Oil & Gas Resources, traveled to Washington, DC, to explain to the U.S. House Natural Resources Committee that Ohio’s hydraulic fracturing and Class II injection well program is properly regulated by the state — and has a track record to prove it. As Energy In Depth has extensively covered, Ohio imposes more stringent regulation than even the federal EPA, which has jurisdiction over injection wells. When the state improved their oversight with Senate Bill 315, existing regulation was already lauded by STRONGER, an EPA-supported review group composed of state regulators and other experts.

Simmers told the committee that his inspectors can enforce regulation properly because they live in operating areas and can reach emergencies and inspections quickly. He said Ohio has issued 596 permits for horizontal development in the Utica Shale, and of those, 293 have been drilled and 81 and have been completed. He said their team of fifty field inspectors is doing a great job and can hire more if needed:

“We welcome any review of our program because we’re doing a great job. We are both better suited and better situated to run this program than the federal EPA.”—Rick Simmers (Official testifies on Ohio fracking oversight, 4/17/13)

When the D&L Energy and Hardrock Excavating incidents were brought up during the testimony, Simmers explained they could be used as an example of ODNR doing its job:

“If it was not for the on-the-ground efforts of ODNR’s oil and gas inspectors, this criminal and environmentally threatening illegal activity of dumping oilfield waste directly into the Mahoning River could still be occurring. Only with the proper resources and experienced staff could this type of action have been executed so swiftly.”—Rick Simmers (Official testifies on Ohio fracking oversight, 4/17/13)

Without proper research, some would disagree Ohio is doing a great job. An out-of-state reporter from — part of the Beaver County Times – claimed that Ohio is essentially a disaster zone with little to no regulatory oversight:

“Despite a history marked with fracking catastrophes, Ohio still wants to retain oversight of its hydraulic fracturing and wastewater disposal industry.”–Rachel Morgan (Ohio tells feds: Stay off fracking, 4/18/13)

Ohio has no history of “fracking catastrophes”— convenient how the specific examples of incidents from fracking were omitted, isn’t it?— and that’s due to strong state oversight. Morgan instead focuses on the dubious fracking-earthquake nexus that she tried to invent a few months ago, citing a handful of specific events instead of the thousands upon thousands of wells that have operated without incident. But why would an actual reporter bother with such details?

For the sake of discussion, however, let’s now look at just how stringent Ohio’s regulation of oil and gas truly is, contrary to the narrative that wants us all to believe.

Energy In Depth has made many comparisons between ODNR’s regulation and the federal regulation it bests. Since Ohio received primacy of the UIC program in 1983, over 200 million barrels of brine have been processed without a single case of groundwater contamination. Environmentalists recently expressed a desire for oversight by the federal government, which means they are ironically pushing for more lax regulation (albeit with an EPA they feel they can manipulate much more easily). Here are some examples of how ODNR’s rules are more stringent than the federal EPA’s:"


Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Natural Gas Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Need help thanks in advance Aug '16 Brey2326 1
Private natural gas well (Jan '06) Aug '16 David Mitchell 772
News Power generating station beginning to take shape (Jan '08) Jun '16 how they get thei... 121
News TranCanada donates $200K to rink expansion project (Nov '12) May '16 how things get OK... 8
News Worker injured at TransCanada plant (Mar '10) Apr '16 tricky trusts en ... 9
News Power company hunting Harry Apr '16 Flo 1
Natural Gas in my well water Naturally occurrin... (Jan '11) Mar '16 janiegirl1948 9
More from around the web