Replay reversal gives Murphy HR as Me...

Replay reversal gives Murphy HR as Mets win

There are 28 comments on the Newsday story from May 27, 2009, titled Replay reversal gives Murphy HR as Mets win. In it, Newsday reports that:

New York Mets' Luis Castillo , gets tangled with Washington Nationals' Ryan Zimmerman , as he advances to third base on a hit by David Wright in the first inning Jerry Manuel said the other night that he likes baseball's use of instant replay.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Newsday.

First Prev
of 2
Next Last

United States

#23 May 28, 2009
Cleon Jones wrote:
<quoted text> If you think I missed spelled Cleon Jones you should start watching womens golf.
You "misspelled" miss spelled, missed spelled.

That is what the DOINK is trying to PROVE!

Old Bridge, NJ

#26 May 28, 2009
Gay Jim AOL wrote:
I'm surprised no lowly Yankee scum came in here yet to s h i t on the parade. When that ball hit the subway sign it reminded me of Lidle's plane and that building on the lower-west side.
Probably uncalled for, I love to bash the Yankees like the next guy.

Old Bridge, NJ

#27 May 28, 2009
CHILL OUT wrote:
<quoted text>
You "misspelled" miss spelled, missed spelled.
That is what the DOINK is trying to PROVE!
So this individual tells me to watch womes Golf because he cant spell correctly in any of his three posts.

We all make mistakes; but it is too funny when the next two also have spelling errors in the word "misspelled". Too much irony.

You calling me a DOINK is just plain hurtful.

I might tell my mommy.

Since: Jul 08

Greensboro, NC

#28 May 28, 2009
Will wrote:
No they are tied for first at 27-20. Red Sox lost last night.<quoted text>
Thank you. They must put my paper to bed very early here.
B M Ryan

Keller, TX

#29 May 28, 2009
Will wrote:
I agree with you about the height of the walls, they should be changed. That gap in right center took away Wright's HR alley.
You're also right the Jackie Robinson part is too much. It could have been part of the rotunda with the rest dedicated to past Met teams and players. If you sat in the overhang you might change your mind. It's a great view and the intention was for the fans to be closer and feel a part of the game. It succeeded there. <quoted text>
....How can anyone sitting above the sign see what is happening directly UNDER the overhang?


Since: Oct 07


#31 May 28, 2009
Just Sheff-Roid being Sheff-Roid. The way pissy Los Mets fans cried about can't be happy now that Los Mets are winning with a known cheater.

Beacon, NY

#32 May 28, 2009
I feel like everyone who says the ball changed direction is blind. it definitely disappeared but it reappeared right on schedule.
blah blah

Islandia, NY

#33 May 29, 2009
I think that the umps missed the call not because of whether or not it was a home run (personally I think it was) but that the rule states it must be clear indisputable evidence to overrule the call. Regardless of what side you stand on it being a home run there was definitely not enough evidence to overrule. The right thing to do would have been to let the original call stand but at the same time I am a Mets fan and happy to see them get another "W". Call me superstitious but I believe we will see this come back to haunt the team later in the season.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 2
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Ryan Zimmerman Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Scherzer excels, Zimmerman debuts as Nats tie C... (Mar '16) Mar '16 Fart news 1
News Issues develop in loss to Atlanta (Apr '14) Apr '14 Teezzyy 1
News Gee, strange play send Mets over Nationals 5-1 (Jul '13) Jul '13 Tom2Tone 1
News New York Mets: What Recent Slide Means for Davi... (Jul '12) Jul '12 XFlushing Fan 1
News Washington Nationals call up Bryce Harper from ... (Apr '12) Apr '12 Mets Fan Forever 1
News Ryan Zimmerman Ready To Return (Jun '11) Jun '11 Baseball fan 1
News Nationals should feel buyer's remorse with Werth (May '11) May '11 The Great Responder 1
More from around the web