What Would You Buy? 2009 Carrera S Or BMW M3?

Tag Links: 2009 Porsche Carrera S , 2008 BMW M3 What Would You Buy? 2009 Carrera S Or BMW M3? Now that the 2009 Porsche 911 Carrera S has upped the ante with a 385HP engine, awesome PDK tranny, bluetooth and ...

[Aaron]

I just love the ///M, I'd have to vote for that.

[NYM]

Porsches can beat cars with almost 2x more power. Things like the M3, M5 and M6 have plenty of power but they can't put the power down. Top Gear took a V10 M6 and a 911 and the 911 had a quicker lap time. so the porsche wins. If it beats an M6, it can beat an M3. Only good M3 is the CSL.

[Bake]

Having owned BMW and Porsche I would lean towards the 911. When you sit in a 911 you feel you are a part of the car. When you sit in the M3 you feel like you are in something special but still just along for the ride.