Who wrote Dasam Granth?

Who wrote Dasam Granth?

There are 41 comments on the India eNews story from Jun 20, 2006, titled Who wrote Dasam Granth?. In it, India eNews reports that:

Fiction, sex and sleaze are the key words of a controversial book "Dasam Granth Da Likhari Kaun? . The book is bound to blow up the controversy over authenticity of - Dasam Granth' purported to be written by ...

Join the discussion below, or Read more at India eNews.

Babbar

Fresno, CA

#29 Apr 21, 2011
87tuti wrote:
tell me please waht is the dasam granth
isnt tht wht u r doing listening to wht someone else is telling. Aren't u illiterate by urself. I agree u should read Dasam Granth by urself. But how many of us understand the meaning of words of Gurbani. U need to be fluent like have as much study as Doctor degree in each language tht is used in Dasam Granth. Try reading it by using a valid translation. read it as whole to understand the concept. not by some line here and some there to find a fault. Lets start with a Novel reading. U read page 134 of a novel and skipped others. It tells the main character of novel is stupid, greedy, drunk. So u imagine this is how the main character is by reading 1 page. Now if u read the page 133( u didnt read it) it clearly tells tht someone else believed the main character is not all wht others believed about it as told in page 133 and page 135 (after 134)explains tht main character is not drunk, greedy or stupid he is opposite. Now if u and others who read the whole novel have a debate about the qualities of the main character. U will say he is drunk but others say opposite. Now tell me who is right. If u will go by wht this man is telling in video i would send u hundreds of examples why u should not read Guru Granth Sahib.
Babbar

Fresno, CA

#30 Apr 21, 2011
Lets start with a Novel reading. U read page 134 of a novel and skipped others. It tells the main character of novel is stupid, greedy, drunk. So u imagine this is how the main character is by reading 1 page. Now if u read the page 133( u didnt read it) it clearly tells tht someone else believed the main character is drunk and page 135 (U did not read it) explains tht main character is not drunk, greedy or stupid he is opposite. Now if u and others( they read whole novel) have a debate about the qualities of the main character. U will say he is drunk but others say opposite. Now tell me who is right. If u will go by wht this man is telling in video i would send u hundreds of examples why u should not read Guru Granth Sahib.
Jay Singh

Riverside, NJ

#32 Apr 26, 2011
Our only guru is Sri Guru Granth Sahib, as it says in guru granth sahib ji, guru manio granth...idk why all the sikhs are fighting over it, even the well educated one!! if you read dasam granth yourself, you will know that it definitely is not Guru Gobind Singh ji's writing. it is writing by some hindus to destroy our religion as we all know how many times hindu government had try to destroy our religion before too.
Kaur

Bristow, VA

#33 Apr 26, 2011
Agreed with above
Shamreet

Nunawading, Australia

#34 May 2, 2011
Guru Gobind Singh ji's the one who told us that we have only one Granth and we should respect it as our only Guru then why dont we do that and obey our 10th guru. why do we want to be disrespectful to our 10th guru by bringing up Dasam Granth and paying respects or Dasam Granth instead of Guru Granth Sahib ji. What are we trying to prove by recognizing Dasam Granth that we are wiser that our gurus
gobind singh gandu hai

Rawalpindi, Pakistan

#35 May 2, 2011
gobind singh gandu hai maderchod pata nahi kitney pathano sey gand marwaye hai gobind gandu ney gobind bharwa pathano ka shokra hai behnchod aur is ney tum hinduo ko yai bola hai key pathano sey gand marwao pathano ka lund bohut bara hota hai tum log aik begairat qom ho aur aik neech qom ho
Shamreet

Nunawading, Australia

#38 May 3, 2011
lagta hai tumhari koi personal problem hai otherwise koi bhee gairatmand insaan kisi bhi peer paigambar ke bare me aise nahi bolta tumahra khuda tumhe is galti ke liye muaf kare
gobind singh gandu hai

Karachi, Pakistan

#39 May 4, 2011
meri koi personal problem nahi hai sahi hai na yahan pey tumhey wo nazar nahi araha jo aur muzhubo key barey mai hindu aur sikh bol rahey hain tabhi mai bolney pey majboor howa hoon warna mai nahi bolta
Shamreet

Nunawading, Australia

#40 May 4, 2011
bure ko dekh kar agar sab bure ho jaye to acha kaun hua, mujhe bhi bhut gussa aya tha Guru Gobind Singh jee ke liye jo tumne likha magar maine mohammad jee ke bare mein bura nahi likha kyonki tumahre likne me mohammad jee ka kya kasoor woh to insaniyat se or insano se pyar ki bar karte the. burai ko burai se mat kato mere bhai. Guru jee ke darbar me sab ek jaise the wahan hindu or muslim sab jate the. Jo hindu aur sikh muslim ke bare me bura likhte hai woh khud bure hai aur unka koi dharam nahi woh na to hindu or na hi sikh kehlane ke kabil hai
gobind singh gandu hai

Karachi, Pakistan

#41 May 4, 2011
yai bat hui na aaj key bad mai bhi kisi key barey mai galat nahi likhon ga sahi hai
Shamreet

Nunawading, Australia

#42 May 5, 2011
good!! mujhe khushi hui yeh sun kar. khud bhi nahi likhna or agar koe aur bhi likhe to use bhi pyar se samjhana tanki hum insaniyat ka dharam chla sake jisme insaan dusre insaan se pyar kare nafrat nahi. nafrat karne wale allah, bhagwan or parmatma ko bhi ache nahi lagte
Akrita

Porirua, New Zealand

#43 Mar 2, 2012
Okaaaay, so who exactly wrote the Dasam Granth ?
ABCD

Nottingham, UK

#46 Nov 12, 2012
Bastard brahmins to destroy sikhism from the inside out. Just like they destroy budhism.
Gillette Shaver

Australia

#47 Jan 9, 2013
Fact wrote:
There is no evidence available that Guru Gobind Singh wrote, authenticated or sanctified any Dasami Patshahi Da Granth in his own hands as was done by him in the case of Damdami version of Guru Granth Sahib in 1706 and 1708 and similar to Guru Arjan Dev in the case of Aad Granth in 1604. The framing of the Rehat Maryada in 1927-1946 was a monumental task. There were several Rehat Maryadas prevailing at that time. The best of the practical life of Sikhs over generations, oral history and written sources available were taken into consideration. All sources confirmed the Sikh concept of Guru Panth and Guru Granth. The Bani of Guru Granth Sahib was the sole canon to accept or reject any idea, concept or suggestion. Dasam Granth, therefore has no recognition in Sikh Rahat Maryada and the 1925 Sikh Gurudwara Act. The Banis of the tenth Guru that have been accepted in the Sikh Rahat Maryada which and sanctified by Guru Panth (1927-1945) are final and unquestionable: Jaap Sahib, ten Swayyas (Swarg Sudu Waley 21-30 Akal Ustat), Benti Chaupai up to Dushat dokh tay, 1st Pauri of Ardas, Dohra and Swayyas in Rehras (as sanctioned in Rehat Maryada).
So much proof of sikh fuddy, what else do we need??
Nihang Singh

Ludhiana, India

#48 Nov 23, 2013
The compositions present in Dasam Granth were written by Gur Gobind Singh in his life span. The Granth was compiled later on by Khalsa which is collection of Hymns of Guru Gobind Singh.

All Sikh historical books/Manuscripts have references of Dasam Granth and it's hymns written by Guru Gobind Singh.

But few members of Ram Raiyas and Meenas ignore those facts/hide those facts and continue their fake preachings for sake of revenge because their ancestors were burnt by Gur Gobind Singh.
raj

Central District, Hong Kong

#49 Nov 23, 2013
yea only kanjar can write a kanjar kavita
sikhjeet

Fresno, CA

#50 Dec 24, 2013
Mr Aurangzeb
I would not go down to vulgarity like you,in civil discourse. Let us talk like a human being with logic. If you are really Muslim and know little about your Holy book, you should know that during the life time of Mohammad nothing was written. Quran was not existing in written form. It was just a word of mouth. When Ali became Calipha. Mohammad's teenage wife persuaded him to compile quran. It was almost 26 years after Mohammads death. May be just to keep the legacy of her husband. So no one knows, for sure how much was Mohammads teaching and how much was Ayesha's and ali's own views in quran. It is silly to say that those all words are from GOD. If God wanted, he would have made Mohammad capable to write and dictated the entire quran. But it never happened. On the other hand Adi Granth was dictated, corrected, edited and put in one volume by 5th guru. So Adi Granth is more athentic than any other religious granth in the world. As for as Dasam Granth is concerned , 90% sikhs don't believe that it was written by tenth master.
So please be civil and rational. What ever you want to believe ,we have no problem. But degrading others is real sign of intellectual shallowness.
Kanneidian Lun

Lakemba, Australia

#51 Dec 24, 2013
sikhjeet wrote:
Mr Aurangzeb
I would not go down to vulgarity like you,in civil discourse. Let us talk like a human being with logic. If you are really Muslim and know little about your Holy book, you should know that during the life time of Mohammad nothing was written. Quran was not existing in written form. It was just a word of mouth. When Ali became Calipha. Mohammad's teenage wife persuaded him to compile quran. It was almost 26 years after Mohammads death. May be just to keep the legacy of her husband. So no one knows, for sure how much was Mohammads teaching and how much was Ayesha's and ali's own views in quran. It is silly to say that those all words are from GOD. If God wanted, he would have made Mohammad capable to write and dictated the entire quran. But it never happened. On the other hand Adi Granth was dictated, corrected, edited and put in one volume by 5th guru. So Adi Granth is more athentic than any other religious granth in the world. As for as Dasam Granth is concerned , 90% sikhs don't believe that it was written by tenth master.
So please be civil and rational. What ever you want to believe ,we have no problem. But degrading others is real sign of intellectual shallowness.
but that guru was not credible. he wasn't even a honest person known to the mainstream. He was a crook who wasn't any good . Where as Mohammed Came and showed and proved who he was and who was he working, The One God.
Sikh God is all crook with no afterlife , heaven or Karma, Sikh God Encourages Crime , Rape, Murder , deceit and Thuggery.
raj

Stockholm, Sweden

#52 Dec 26, 2013
sikhjeet wrote:
Mr Aurangzeb
I would not go down to vulgarity like you,in civil discourse. Let us talk like a human being with logic. If you are really Muslim and know little about your Holy book, you should know that during the life time of Mohammad nothing was written. Quran was not existing in written form. It was just a word of mouth. When Ali became Calipha. Mohammad's teenage wife persuaded him to compile quran. It was almost 26 years after Mohammads death. May be just to keep the legacy of her husband. So no one knows, for sure how much was Mohammads teaching and how much was Ayesha's and ali's own views in quran. It is silly to say that those all words are from GOD. If God wanted, he would have made Mohammad capable to write and dictated the entire quran. But it never happened. On the other hand Adi Granth was dictated, corrected, edited and put in one volume by 5th guru. So Adi Granth is more athentic than any other religious granth in the world. As for as Dasam Granth is concerned , 90% sikhs don't believe that it was written by tenth master.
So please be civil and rational. What ever you want to believe ,we have no problem. But degrading others is real sign of intellectual shallowness.
i have many muslims friends they told me that koran is the only book you can memorize by heart and it is proof you fool no body can changed it is evident till today I have seem my self and u can see too even 2 years old can memorized it so it have totally proof that it cannot changed and it is not a copy like guru granth , yr guru have copy of our hindu texts and one more thing many guru have their potis but it did not included in yr guru granth , and in last of guru granth I thing rangmala is believed yr guru have not composed it
Then how come it added to guru granth sahib and where is the orignal guru granth of guru gobind have written
Aman Arora

Mumbai, India

#53 May 21, 2014
Ghar bhej dijiye

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Poetry Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News American Writers Museum to open in Chicago in May 9 hr Trump is the man 1
News The road to truth and reconciliation is paved w... Feb 14 reconciliation eh 1
The Reasons Why Feb 13 Mark Rosenkranz 1
News Elissa Ball's Punk Poetry (Sep '13) Jan '17 Nancy 2
News The mysterious life of America's most popular p... Jan '17 Faith Michigan 2
News Averse to Trump, America's poets fight back wit... Jan '17 2brosewilder 89
News Writers of all ages prove to be poetry in motio... (Apr '07) Dec '16 Salute the BRAC S... 3
More from around the web