TBI charges Claiborne man with child rape

“The Lone Skeptic”

Joined: May 8, 2007

Comments: 5752

ISP: United States

Judged:

Just wanted to alert folks so that they'd have almost a week to plan alternate routes instead of being stuck in traffic on Monday.

Happy motoring, all.

“The Lone Skeptic”

Joined: May 8, 2007

Comments: 5752

ISP: United States

Judged:

Oops--somehow that got attached to the wrong article...

“The Lone Skeptic”

Joined: May 8, 2007

Comments: 5752

ISP: United States

Judged:

Now as to this article, how on earth can anyone do what this man is accused of doing? If he is guilty, he needs to go away for a long, long time.

Interpid

Dover, DE

Judged:

I don't understand how a parent can't tell that something is wrong with their kid.. especially a little girl of 11...Maybe when they are teens they shut down and keep things to themselves, but at 11? I think I could tell that something was amiss...And, you are right NightSerf...I'd prefer stiffer punishment than you (LOL),but I'd go with a long prison sentence...

“The Lone Skeptic”

Joined: May 8, 2007

Comments: 5752

You know me--I believe in working within the framework of the law. I'd no more advocate punishments beyond its limits for these crimes than I would commit them myself. But in many of the cases I've followed over the years, the sentences have been less than the minimum specified by the legislature, and that bothers me, too, especially in cases where children have been victimized. Our children are the most precious of all beings in our society, and harming them is the gravest of all violations of trust. It's hard to imagine any mitigating factors that justify a shred of lenience.

Harry Odil

NightSerf wrote:

Now as to this article, how on earth can anyone do what this man is accused of doing? If he is guilty, he needs to go away for a long, long time.

Very well said , NightSerf . Also your later comment about working within the law . It makes you wonder if the judges who are handing out these terribly weak sentences would react differently if it were their daughter who were raped .

O NO

I think parenting has something to do with it all the girls in that family have or is dating OLD men and while they were underage!

spade caller

Judged:

I heard someone that knows this man say this isn't true that the guy is 100% homo.

Not Me

Judged:

When I read the headlines I thought David Ray was up to his old tricks again.

Interpid

Dover, DE

Judged:

You stupid backward clods! This PEDOPHILE admitted that he had sex with her at a young age.. He's 45 years old now for God's sake! And, your defending him tells me all I need to know about ya'll too....

Ms Coffee

Ooltewah, TN

Judged:

Even if she was willing, that does not change the fact that she was a child. It shouldn't matter what kind of person she is, if she is on drugs, sells them or not. He is old enough to be her father, he should have known better.

Crying Indian

Joined: Apr 2, 2009

Comments: 663

Judged:

sixteen? You think she would have spoke up before she moved in with him. Sounds like some kind of game to me.

honest truth

Judged:

yes she was 16 not 11 that damn lie she had already screwed half the county so yall say what you want he did not do it he was set up all the way around it all come out in court

counslor

Judged:

i think she sold drugs to ms coffee that girls been in cherokee mental health she has told lies all her life she need to be put in state custody before she gets her self hurt by telling lies and snitching on everyone that she sold or bought drugs from

Who

Ooltewah, TN

Judged:

Who is the girl?

O NO

Judged:

Who wrote:

Who is the girl?

Lisa spradlin thats who it b

“The Lone Skeptic”

Joined: May 8, 2007

Comments: 5752

ISP: Louisville, TN

According to the article, the abuse began when she was 11, but she didn't have a baby until she was 16, which means she was probably 15 at the time of the conception. I might be skeptical if the charges were being made by relatively untrained small town police, but these charges come from the TBI, a well trained unit that adheres to national standards.

This might be a trial worth watching when it comes up. I hope that those who are following it closely will post in this forum when jury selection begins.

close by

Judged:

i know that he never raped the girl and this is bull shit i have lived beside all this shit for years and i got all the proof he needs to show the truth that i just took to the district attorney office her dad evens knows better but she was under 18 but her family was well aware of it she took over his life only thing he got good out this is a kid that will have a fucked up life now for sure

Crying Indian

Joined: Apr 2, 2009

Comments: 663

Judged:

If they do show the trial, wouldn't her face just be a blurry spot? The guy sounds retarded

dude